Flying Crane
Sr. Grandmaster
Then maybe rackemann would do a better job if he qualified his comments more. Honestly, when I start to read things like his blog, my first thought is “yet another wack-job who thinks he knows it all” and I rarely finish reading it. If he has a message he wants to get out, he does a pretty poor job except when preaching to the choir.There really is no need to post in such an adversarial tone.
I agree with Anarax to a large degree. Like anyone who has a theme and is trying to make a point in a blog post, I think Rackemann is guilty of somewhat "overstating" his case in most of these blogs he writes. But he does make some excellent points, and ones that do often apply to "traditional" schools. I do believe that you can't generalize what he says to ALL "traditional" martial arts, and he would probably tell you the same thing. And a lot of what he says could also apply to the local boxing gym or MMA gym. But most of his points are well-founded. Rackemann never said that he is the only one that "doesn't suck" and "has it all figured out."
Again, this article was all about the "mindset" of a lot of traditional martial arts. Obviously you can't generalize it to ALL of them, but I've seen it as well. If you don't have this "mindset", then you have nothing to worry about.