cutting punch

[guy b]

And it requires a pivot and rising elbow while on the inside in order to work. It's a workaround.

And not lsdd

 

[Nobody Important]

And it requires a pivot and rising elbow while on the inside in order to work. It's a workaround.

Call it whatever you want. I don't see how you can call it a work around if you utilize a Biu Sau in any manner. It would be the exact same move. Seems to me you're just bitter, though I can't image over what.

 

[guy b]

All this back & forth could be cleared up if you would simply answer the question, What is your "elbow ideas".

The reason would be so that you aren't able to just claim them as your own, as you have done many times before. This is why it is useful to talk things through to get a clear idea of where others stand before revealing details.

Being evasive and dishonest doesn't help speed this process.

 

[LFJ]

You and I clearly have different ideas about raising an elbow. I view the movement as one coordinated movement of three joints.

You either raise it or you don't.

You are fixated on the elbow.

The discussion has always been about the elbow.

It is physically impossible to strike high without the elbow being inline with the wrist and shoulder. It is a hinge joint and lifts when extended.

You need to revisit SNT.

 

[Nobody Important]

And not lsdd

If it strikes the opponent and effectively negates his strike in the process, how is it not lsdd?

 

[LFJ]

Call it whatever you want. I don't see how you can call it a work around if you utilize a Biu Sau in any manner. It would be the exact same move. Seems to me you're just bitter, though I can't image over what.

Biu-sau is not used as a basic punching idea.

 

[Nobody Important]

The reason would be so that you aren't able to just claim them as your own, as you have done many times before. This is why it is useful to talk things through to get a clear idea of where others stand before revealing details.

Being evasive and dishonest doesn't help speed this process.

Bahahahaha!!!! That's rich. Neither one of you has answered one question, yet you feel entitled to the milk of everyone else's cow. You're welcome.

 

[Nobody Important]

Biu-sau is not used as a basic punching idea.

Outside of hand position is it any different than a punch?

 

[Nobody Important]

You either raise it or you don't.



The discussion has always been about the elbow.



You need to revisit SNT.

OK if you say so grasshopper. Not my fault you convolute and can't comprehend the simplest of things.

 

[guy b]

Bahahahaha!!!! That's rich. Neither one of you has answered one question, yet you feel entitled to the milk of everyone else's cow. You're welcome.

Many questions have been answered over a long period of time. The drift of answers in light of this new info is very revealing in terms of what others actually know

 

[guy b]

If it strikes the opponent and effectively negates his strike in the process, how is it not lsdd?

Lsdd is not hand chasing

 

[guy b]

You need to revisit SNT.

This is absolutely the issue. The understanding is missing

 

[LFJ]

Outside of hand position is it any different than a punch?

Not yours, apparently. You are neither confirming nor denying this is your punch at 1:10?

 

[Nobody Important]

Looks to me like the elbow is rising on every strike, exactly as I explained. Tell me, how is it wrong again?

 

[Nobody Important]

Not yours, apparently. You are neither confirming nor denying this is your punch at 1:10?

Didn't watch it. I presented another example instead.

 

[KPM]

The reason would be so that you aren't able to just claim them as your own, as you have done many times before. This is why it is useful to talk things through to get a clear idea of where others stand before revealing details.

Being evasive and dishonest doesn't help speed this process.

Again, utter and total BS! You are so full of it that it isn't even entertaining anymore!

 

[KPM]

Lsdd is not hand chasing

And again....you didn't answer his question.

 

[Nobody Important]

Lsdd is not hand chasing

Never said it was, I also said that you don't intentionally try to perform a gate punch several times. Pay attention.

 

[Nobody Important]

In case you missed it the first time. His elbow comes up on every strike just as I described. Impossible for it not to. Now unless WSL is doing it wrong, I think perhaps you two should revisit SNT.

Care to explain these "elbow ideas" now? Because I'm not picking up what your pretending is lacking with everyone else in this video.

 

[LFJ]

Looks to me like the elbow is rising on every strike, exactly as I explained. Tell me, how is it wrong again?

What exactly are you calling a strike in the form?

And why are you afraid of having your gate punch pinned down? Are you not confident about it?