In large part, these types of kicks are going to require several things that aren't likely outside of a sport-setting i.e. distance, range, a non-aggressive attacker (one that is willing to stand there during the time it takes to complete the kick rather than closing the distance, and have their hands low).
In large part, I think agree with you.
It would be difficult to do a tornado kick on someone who's bull-rushing you.
I don't totally agree with the hands low thing, though. People get kicked in the face in kickboxing and MMA all the time, even when holding a high guard. You just have to get around that.
Can it possibly be used in a SD situation. Sure, anything can giving the right set of circumstances. If the guy is drunk for example, perhaps a little wobbly an not able to close the distance quickly and/or effectively.
Well sometimes even on the street two guys just square up like it's a boxing match. You know, one guy says something that pisses another one off, they have words, and its fight time.
But then again, if you're in close quarters i.e. between a couple of parked cars it would be a lot simpler (and vastly more effective) to do a low kick to the knee or instep. And of course I'd hate to see someone in tight jeans that isn't warmed up (unlike these competitors who have warmed up and stretched out and have the luxury of loose-fitting clothing). Or someone in high heels or ....you get the picture. It is a low % defense that requires too many circumstance to line up in order to pull off.
I agree that you should use the appropriate technique at the appropriate time. Luckily our martial arts systems have a wide variety of techniques, far more than any of us can really master.
It looks pretty though. But not really martial art.
I wouldn't say that. If it can be used--under any circumstances--then it may be art, but it's also martial.
Some random street thugs will be untrained i.e. the drunk guy I mentioned. But some have trained. Everyone needs to understand that jails and prisons are breeding grounds for criminals to become better criminals whether it is more effective ways to break into a house or more effective ways to stab you or take your head off with an assault. We have videos of this type of training. It can't be stopped. So that random thug you face on the street might be some awkward newbie to fighting that you can blow through easily. Or, it can be that guy that is on parole that doesn't particularly care if he trashes your face and has learned fist-fighting pretty well in prison (on top of the knife or shank he's armed himself with for just such an occasion). Which do you think is more likely to pick a fight with you? After the fight is a lousy time to find out which guy he was.
That's a good point. Considering my rather diminutive size (about 5'6", 160 lbs), really, I would rather carry a gun than rely on my hand-to-hand skills in a true, life-or-death encounter anyway.