- Joined
- Mar 5, 2005
- Messages
- 9,930
- Reaction score
- 1,452
It's a BFK (Big ***** Knife :lol: )
Not really a part of wing chun, either-since it's a northern shaolin weapon...:lfao:
BJJ vs Wing Chun (joke joke!)
- Thread starter KamonGuy2
- Start date
It's a BFK (Big ***** Knife :lol: )
Not really a part of wing chun, either-since it's a northern shaolin weapon...:lfao:
Yoshiyahu
Master Black Belt
here above is a kwan dao.
above is da dao
i think these weapons would greatly with Wing Chun...
Makes a great weapon for the house incase of intruders.
chase them off the front yard.
Yoshi, do you actually train? I ask this because the forum has loads of your threads entitled "How do you train against...." and asking how you do this technique and that technique. Also you've had the ground v standup thread as well. Many of your posts have been irate because other posters haven't answered the way you thought they should or haven't provided the information you wanted.
The information available on MT is amazing but annoying the hell out of other posters may not be the best way to access that information!
The information available on MT is amazing but annoying the hell out of other posters may not be the best way to access that information!
JadecloudAlchemist
Master of Arts
If someone is coming at you with a long range weapon closing the gap example clinching would most likely make the Kwan do useless in a grappling situation and most likely the person using the Kwan do would be at a disadvantage grappling with it. However the person using the Kwan do would be at the greatest advantage at long range because that is what the weapon is designed for.
So yes BJJ and grappling would be useful against a Kwando at close range.
So yes BJJ and grappling would be useful against a Kwando at close range.
dungeonworks
Black Belt
- Joined
- May 7, 2006
- Messages
- 540
- Reaction score
- 18
Glock.
Okay, buh-bye, and take yer little red wagon with you, m'kay? :lfao:
That was pretty funny....but would not a Springfield XD, say the one with the 6" barrell in .40 cal. work as well? :shooter::lfao:
dungeonworks
Black Belt
- Joined
- May 7, 2006
- Messages
- 540
- Reaction score
- 18
No, don't take it that nobody has a defense against it....take it as nobody knows what the hell a kwan dao is. Now that you posted a picture, I have seen these before in them wire-fu kung fu movies...Hidden Dragon, Crouching Tiger or whatever. Nobody can take that serious. Nobody carries those, and if they did, they'd be violating several laws in the process....heck, you couldn't even conceal it! LOL
So no, nobody I know of trains for or against this. Nobody I know even wants to....and how does a slashing weapon work along Wing Chun principles??? I could see if it were stabbing/piercing in natuture, but that behemoth is clearly a slashing weapon.
dungeonworks
Black Belt
- Joined
- May 7, 2006
- Messages
- 540
- Reaction score
- 18
Haven't you noticed he does this to all threads started by others, especially if BJJ or wrestling are involved? He does get a little nasty when his threads are off-tracked though.
Yoshiyahu
Master Black Belt
I am sorry you hate my threads and post. Many of you are not like minded...so my ideas and thoughts will not make you happy. I am fine with that. I am longer trying to kiss **** and act fake. But I am simply being me.
As for my questions these may things I have thought of or experience. Anyway If you don't like my question why do you read them an why you respond.
If you feel there is defense against Kwan Dao that is on you. One simple thing would be to learn the Kwan Dao and also have one for yourself. But this is a mere opinion. But I have been thinking about what weapons I might to add. I think Kwan Dao and Da Dao it is. So from you guys dont believe its defendable. That means It is good invest for me.
Dungeon works doesn't the short swords slash...What does Bart Cham Dao mean?
also what about this?
BJJ vs Wing Chun (joke joke!)
This is the thread...a joke joke joke..
As for my questions these may things I have thought of or experience. Anyway If you don't like my question why do you read them an why you respond.
If you feel there is defense against Kwan Dao that is on you. One simple thing would be to learn the Kwan Dao and also have one for yourself. But this is a mere opinion. But I have been thinking about what weapons I might to add. I think Kwan Dao and Da Dao it is. So from you guys dont believe its defendable. That means It is good invest for me.
Dungeon works doesn't the short swords slash...What does Bart Cham Dao mean?
also what about this?
BJJ vs Wing Chun (joke joke!)
This is the thread...a joke joke joke..
Yoshi, do you actually train? I ask this because the forum has loads of your threads entitled "How do you train against...." and asking how you do this technique and that technique. Also you've had the ground v standup thread as well. Many of your posts have been irate because other posters haven't answered the way you thought they should or haven't provided the information you wanted.
The information available on MT is amazing but annoying the hell out of other posters may not be the best way to access that information!
Steve
Mostly Harmless
Is that a Kwan Dao in your pocket, or are you just happy to see me?
Yoshiyahu
Master Black Belt
The main who could fit a kwan dao in his pocket is way to big to be fighting. Not even the Incredible Hulk can take him.
I am not sure if bullets would work on that fellow either. You better try a scud missle.
I am not sure if bullets would work on that fellow either. You better try a scud missle.
Is that a Kwan Dao in your pocket, or are you just happy to see me?
- Thread Starter
- #92
You are a valued member....
...of the troll community...
Trouble is Yoshi, you come up with idiotic questions (I bet it was you who started the 'Bruce Lee vs Mohammed Lee' debate in the first place) and then get offended by people who poke fun
If people insult your art, your style, your training, or you for no good reason, then yeah sure get angry.
But if you ask a stupid question you are going to get stupid answers
Carrying a knife or weapon down the street is likely to get you very hurt (either by the police or people who have bigger weapons)
If someone comes at me with a broadsword or huge weapon, I am going to go in hard and fast and get them before they get me. I am not going to worry about defence or a particular move
You remind me of an instructor who I fell out with not so long back. He was teaching kids how to defend against rubber knives. The defensive moves were so poor that the kids were getting caught but went away thinking they were heroes
skinters
Blue Belt
- Joined
- Jul 30, 2008
- Messages
- 208
- Reaction score
- 4
sorry m8 i cant ignore this one,you going to go in hard and fast with any sort of attack with a blade? this has been gone over so many times,and the consensus suggests that realisticly you lose against a knife,and all them knife self defence classes are imo incredibly dangerous and misleading.
http://rivrdog.typepad.com/paratus/2006/03/why_you_keep_sh.html take a look at this if you need more convincing.
sounds like you had a flush of blood there :wink2:
Last edited:
dungeonworks
Black Belt
- Joined
- May 7, 2006
- Messages
- 540
- Reaction score
- 18
Good point, I didn't think of that. I'm nowhere near learning the Butterfly Knives let alone how they are used yet. Bart Cham Do....isn't that the Chinese term for Butterfly Swords?
Where do ya'll live that you train for someone attacking you with Butterfly swords/ broadswords, etc!?!?!? lol.
Whatever happened to running?????
There is no shame in running from a person with a big a$$ weapon like those mentioned.
I mean really now...
Come on....
Whatever happened to running?????
There is no shame in running from a person with a big a$$ weapon like those mentioned.
I mean really now...
Come on....
mook jong man
Senior Master
Yes you are correct , it roughly translates to 'Eight Chopping Knives'.
skinters
Blue Belt
- Joined
- Jul 30, 2008
- Messages
- 208
- Reaction score
- 4
i agree.
but learning how to use them in a traditional way as part of your art,is worth striving for.
i feel that some here are thinking of their application in real life situations,ie whats the best defence against a butterfly sword attack.
jeezuz the entertainment value is worth its weight in gold .
you mean i can't catch the sword between the palms of my hands? i call that the prayer sau. the i shift 45 degrees to the right and pak it out of the way. lol
Steve
Mostly Harmless
How would a WC master defend against an attack by an 11th level paladin wielding a +5 Holy Defender?
How would a WC master defend against an attack by an 11th level paladin wielding a +5 Holy Defender?
LOL. man, that s**t is funny. like that pic.
define Defend. thoughts anyone?
would you use close range, long range, gun range combat?
