The essence of Tai Chi push hand kung fu

[windwalker099]

This is going backward (no leg skill allowed). I prefer to go forward and send my students to Sanda instead.

ok

Take it you have not competed in it, nor trained interacted with people who do compete
Correct me if I'm mistaken.

Mention this feeling a lot of questions might be answered...
as to why this or that is done or not.

People I've met in China, Taiwan the range of PH they do is pretty large, as well as intensity...
If you prefer leg skill, some probably wouldn't have much a problem accommodating it.
On the other hand, one might find out why it might not be a good idea to try it....ya never know..

Not a fan of ph, as its practiced by many...
Do use it at times as a kind of testing ground...
meeting people, making friends...

 

[windwalker099]

You continued to come back at me with him trying to justify what he is doing, I can only assume in an attempt to get me to see the error of my ways..

You know what they say about assuming...things

"Justify" some else's work...
Thinking only they can do it..and those that follow it
as in training, or practicing it, finding some value or interest in it.

Others might find it interesting or not...

If you want to post "one liners" as a critique of something or someone.
Please do it on some ones else thread.

If you want to share a presumably informed view point.
by all means continue.

If you say your "done" then be done

no reply needed...

 

[Kung Fu Wang]

Take it you have not competed in it, nor trained interacted with people who do compete

Through my tournament years, I have never competed in any Taiji PH tournament.

 

[Same Trick]

My Shifu was not impressed by him either, did not think he was all that good..... I'm done here, you want to be impressed by him, go for it, but do not expect me to be.

I think his taiji forms performance is really great, there’s absolutely more to it than just for forms competition, I can see that it can bring on jealousy to some.
As for his PH it’s best to try him out on it to be able make a sound judgement.

 

[Same Trick]

Through my tournament years, I have never competed in any Taiji PH tournament.

Neither have I , however now when gettin “older” it’s probably the game of competition I’d enter if I do