Dude, I'm buying!RRouuselot said:Now I'm hungry for Chinese food!
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Dude, I'm buying!RRouuselot said:Now I'm hungry for Chinese food!
I just had Chinese food for dinner........it was outstanding!Aegis said:Damn, now I want Chinese food too! And it's only 10:20 am here!
RRouuselot said:I just had Chinese food for dinner........it was outstanding!
TimoS said:Now you're just being cruel :asian:
RRouuselot said:It wasn't Hong Kong level.............but pretty close!
Robert, in all fairness the stuff that I call Chinese food is probably about as Chinese as I amRRouuselot said:I just had Chinese food for dinner........it was outstanding!
akja said:Do we still need to report to Asia to be legit???[/B]
Although thyere are stylistic things I don't agree with, taking into account age and the process of filming usally brings thins down a little.RRouuselot said:I hate to ask but feel I must get clarification on this......how was he "making history" in 1963?
Well here he is in present day........
http://www.kempokarate.com/tenshi_goju.mov
anyone have any comments about his "technique"?
Don Roley said:I think you are taking a very superficial view of the martial arts. You talk as if all hits, etc are the same. They are not. Some are damaging, some are driving. Take a look at Hsing-i. From what I understand, they have something like five different types of hitting, all with the same type of fist.
Too many people think that martial arts are just the same techniques thrown together in different combinations. I thought so too. But now I see that there is some truely great variations in the arts from the ground up. If someone does not know the total of the art, how are they to judge if it is good or not. What may be "correct" in one art can be "wrong" in another. I have a hell of a time with my shoulders in my current art after the style I started out with.
Penjak Silat, Copierra, Systema, Bagua and Shotokan- are you really going to say that these example arts do not have fundemental differences in the way they approach the situation of combat and declare yourself worthy of judging them all?
I have talked about this before, and here is a greater expansion on how I feel on the matter.
http://www.martialtalk.com/forum/showthread.php?p=377877#post377877
Don Roley said:UpnorthKyosa,
I understand and agree with what you have to say in your last post. But the original point about how a stylist from one art can judge what is right or wrong in another is what I was getting at.
Yes, another art can give you greater insight. It can open you up to possibilities that you have never thought of. The best example is the insight the Gracies gave to the world of strikers. But for someone on a soke council to look at a tape of Bagua when they have never experienced the full art and then judge whether it is "correct' or not is just plain silly IMO.
Nobody asked you to respect anyone. You flat out likened him to jack Stern. That was straight up disrespect on your part. You call it your right to question and I call it disrespect to a senior martial artist.Don Roley said:Do we need to report to a soke board to be legit?
Looking at all the posts here, it all seems to come down to that idea. The idea that Americans should throw off the chains of Asia, stop bowing to Asian master and........
....put on chains made in America and start bowing to American masters.
I look at those that I respect as inovators of the martial arts and can't imagine them pointing to an orginization and saying, "since I belong to this group you should respect me!" Bruce Lee, Ed Parker, The Gracies, etc... I cannot imagine them trying to claim respect from others based on the people they associate with.
And this really seems to be what soke boards are all about. Gaining legitmaticy through their association with others. Reading some folks use of their sokeship council membership, I get the mental image of the South Park line, "Respect my authority!!!!!"
And really, the arguments for soke boards I see here are not so much ones that seem to point to the positive attitude of the groups. Rather they remind me of Eric Cartman running around in his police uniform.
"How dare you judge my hanshi" seems to be the response. Well, that is what Americans do, is it not? We do not bow to kings or feel forced to accept what others tell us. Why the heck should we bow down to your self proclaimed master of the martial art that he is fit to judge others any more than us?
I think it is safe to say that someone without a strong internal Chinese martial art would have problems telling good from bad in that art, or tell why certain things are done the way they are.
Of course, there is the matter of combat effectiveness. I have seen the comments that a person who has spent 50 years in the martial arts should be able to tell what is combat effective. Oh really? I have no trouble imagining that someone could spend decades in the safety of the dojo and not know the first thing about a fight for their life. I remember when the Gracies first came on the scene and many people who had trained for decades said that a striker could beat them silly before they could be taken to the ground. They were proven wrong because they had no real experience going against a grappler.
So if someone does not have a lot of experience in real combat- the only situation where there are not rules and conditions like the strikers faced before facing the Gracies- then I think they are pretty dumb for saying they can judge what will and will not work in combat.
So, where is the proof of these judges experience in life or death combat? I am talking about things like police reports. If someone has to defend his life, it is only natural that the police would be called in. And they had to have done this enough to discount a lucky handfull of experiences to gain the experience worthy of judging others.
So, all the arts that are passed by these mavens teach defense against knife attacks. Are any of them willing to get in a cage with Don Pentecost or Marc MacYoung armed with a live blade? It seems natural that if the judges are willing to give their stamp of approval in terms of combat effectiveness to arts that teach how to defend against a knife that they should face a live one in the hands of someone like that.
But instead those of us that find the qualifications of the mavens wanting are faced with a attempt to intimidate us into respecting the authority of them just like they accuse those in Asia of requiring. I see more in common with Eric Cartman than the words of Bruce Lee.
Well, the simple fact is that until one of these judges produce some police reports of real life and death combat or agree to face even harmless guy like me with a blade in my hand, they deserve no deference to their authority. Until they show some experience in all the multiple arts they cater to I have the right to say that I do not think they are qualified.
And as an American holding the values of questioning anything I want, I will not be told to respect their authority quietly.
akja said:Hanshi is a good man and he does not belong in the "horror stories."
[font=arial,helvetica][font=arial,helvetica][font=Trebuchet MS, Arial, Helvetica]1) He may have gotten the idea from this information:akja said:1)Nobody asked you to respect anyone. You flat out likened him to jack Stern.
2) Hanshi is a good man and he does not belong in the "horror stories."
These are 2 differant organizations.RRouuselot said:jack stern [font=arial,helvetica][font=arial,helvetica][font=Trebuchet MS, Arial, Helvetica]1) He may have gotten the idea from this information:
1995:
Grandmaster Jack Stern was inducted into the Christian Martial Arts Hall of Fame (Golden Life Achievement Award).
Grandmaster Jack Stern was inducted into the World Head of Family Soke Council (Instructor of the Year Award).
World Head of Family Soke Council (Martial Arts Pioneer Award).
2) That's your opinion. Other people think if you are a flag waving card caring member of the bogus [/font][/font][/font][font=arial,helvetica][font=arial,helvetica][font=Trebuchet MS, Arial, Helvetica]World Head of Family Soke Council you are a fake.....
More BS by Jack Stern can be found here:
http://www.kyha.net/awardsrecognition/
[/font][/font][/font]
akja said:These are 2 differant organizations.
http://www.bushido.org/~whfsc/
What article?RRouuselot said:No need to waste all the bandwidth with all the bogus Soke-Doke wannabes......if you would have bothered to read the article I posted Jack Stern was booted out of that organization.
akja said:What article?