K
Kenpo Yahoo
Guest
The "noise" of the KIAI or spirit yell, I was told, gave you the spiritual edge over your opponent. I've even heard stories of people knocking other people out with just a kiai. In my opinion it's all a bunch of hu-hah.
Boxers exhale through their noise, (i.e. mouth closed, jaw tight) to keep their jaws from getting broken when they take a shot. The main reason they exhale when they punch is to tighten up their mid-section (the abdominal wall), for the simple fact that when they throw a punch they create an opening in their defense.
In the case of martial arts it works the same, but "noise" gives you a little extra psychological edge. Afterall, who's crazy enough to yell while they fight . Unfortunately, it won't give you an edge for long, if it does work in that manner. In the case of women, yelling "NO" while executing strikes is pretty normal. The best thing you can do is draw attention (and possibly help) to yourself.
If you are already SURE that you are tightening up and breathing properly without all the yelling, I don't see that much of an added benefit. Most guys that are willing to fight (egotists) aren't going to back down cause you said KIAI.
Let your skill speak for itself.
This is just my opinion, and most probably won't agree.
Boxers exhale through their noise, (i.e. mouth closed, jaw tight) to keep their jaws from getting broken when they take a shot. The main reason they exhale when they punch is to tighten up their mid-section (the abdominal wall), for the simple fact that when they throw a punch they create an opening in their defense.
In the case of martial arts it works the same, but "noise" gives you a little extra psychological edge. Afterall, who's crazy enough to yell while they fight . Unfortunately, it won't give you an edge for long, if it does work in that manner. In the case of women, yelling "NO" while executing strikes is pretty normal. The best thing you can do is draw attention (and possibly help) to yourself.
If you are already SURE that you are tightening up and breathing properly without all the yelling, I don't see that much of an added benefit. Most guys that are willing to fight (egotists) aren't going to back down cause you said KIAI.
Let your skill speak for itself.
This is just my opinion, and most probably won't agree.