Jenny_in_Chico
Black Belt
Wow, this thread has caught fire like a bad case of the clap.
I think I was the first person to say that giving the kids hand tattoos was dooming them to a life at minimum wage jobs. I stand by that statement. Whether we like it or not, mainstream society has unwritten rules about what you "can" and "can't" do if you want to be taken seriously. I'm not anti-tattoo, for the record, I think that guys with tattoos are hot. I've dated guys with tattoos on their faces, necks, hands and inside lower lips. So I'm pretty open to innovative ways of decorating one's body with ink. But guess what? I suspect that all of those guys are constrained with respect to their career choices. It isn't necessarily kind or fair, but that is the way of the world.
With respect to raising kids: let's separate "government" from "society" in this discussion. As a civilized society, we all agree that we have a responsibility toward protecting the physical and mental well-being of children...all children, nt just our own. That means that I personally have a responsibility toward the kids living down the street. If their parents are abusing them, it is my duty as a member of society to do something about it. "Government" is the official arm of society, and it is necessary because we no longer live in tiny tribes and can't take our personal gripes to a single person for a solution. We imbue the government with certain powers, so that the rules we all agree to live by can be administered fairly. So we allow the government to step in and interfere in cases where we as a society agree that it is desirable. In essence, we create a middleman between individual members of society and society as a whole. So instead of me walking down the street and punching someone in the melon for abusing their children, I call Child Protective Services and report the abuse. We as a society have agreed that children are people with limited power and in a unique state of vulnerability, and although parents should be allowed to exercise a large amount of freedom in how they are raised, they aren't allowed to do everything they want. In this case, irrespective of the "harm" that the kids may experience years down the road from having hand tattoos, it cannot be denied that the parents stabbed them with a needle multiple times. That is abuse by anyone's definition.
I think I was the first person to say that giving the kids hand tattoos was dooming them to a life at minimum wage jobs. I stand by that statement. Whether we like it or not, mainstream society has unwritten rules about what you "can" and "can't" do if you want to be taken seriously. I'm not anti-tattoo, for the record, I think that guys with tattoos are hot. I've dated guys with tattoos on their faces, necks, hands and inside lower lips. So I'm pretty open to innovative ways of decorating one's body with ink. But guess what? I suspect that all of those guys are constrained with respect to their career choices. It isn't necessarily kind or fair, but that is the way of the world.
With respect to raising kids: let's separate "government" from "society" in this discussion. As a civilized society, we all agree that we have a responsibility toward protecting the physical and mental well-being of children...all children, nt just our own. That means that I personally have a responsibility toward the kids living down the street. If their parents are abusing them, it is my duty as a member of society to do something about it. "Government" is the official arm of society, and it is necessary because we no longer live in tiny tribes and can't take our personal gripes to a single person for a solution. We imbue the government with certain powers, so that the rules we all agree to live by can be administered fairly. So we allow the government to step in and interfere in cases where we as a society agree that it is desirable. In essence, we create a middleman between individual members of society and society as a whole. So instead of me walking down the street and punching someone in the melon for abusing their children, I call Child Protective Services and report the abuse. We as a society have agreed that children are people with limited power and in a unique state of vulnerability, and although parents should be allowed to exercise a large amount of freedom in how they are raised, they aren't allowed to do everything they want. In this case, irrespective of the "harm" that the kids may experience years down the road from having hand tattoos, it cannot be denied that the parents stabbed them with a needle multiple times. That is abuse by anyone's definition.