Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
For the TMA or Self Defense types.
Take out the eye gouges, groin shots, accept the fact that maybe one shot wont take out a superbly conditioned athlete when protection is wrapped around your hand, stop small joint manipulation and finger tears, dont use the enviornment (cage in this instance) and weapons, accept sport strategies (point count, aggresiveness for points), dont think about him pulling out a weapon, no neck strikes, no stomps to the knee, no nose or ear pulls. Modify all of this, which for some styles is all that they are or a big majority of their syllabus, conform to the popular and effective standard to make up what you dont have for this situation, and you maybe you can succeed in mma. Simple as that, and has been done before.
But dont forgot what you lost to get there, and its up to you to decide if it was all worth it or not.
Now keep in mind that any "traditional" style that does all those likely either doesn't spar at all, or spars and competes under rules that are far more limiting then those used in MMA.
But if you are from a school where nose and ear pulls are a major part of sparring, please post some videos set to benny hill music.
I think it’s difficult to say MMA this or TMA that at any length, I mean that’s such a generality that it really needs to be qualified by a specific example. I know we’re speaking in terms of opinion, everyone is entitled to their own, but personally I could not say what “most” TMA or MMA schools do. Again, I have to state that MMA is such a loose term (not to say TMA isn’t).
Not unless you are mixing the arts. I train in three different arts currently and have trained in three others previously.I suppose you could call yourself a “Mixed Martial Artist” the second you train in another martial art.
I don't disagree with this. My point was to highlight MMA as an idea (generic) vs. the popular, specific notion that you refer to. I think The MMA raises consciousness about the generic concept which I ascribe to.Likewise, when you say MMA, people know that you are talking about the sport, not the generic of simply mixing martial arts.
Logically I agree but in practice I blend the multiple styles I study. I have trained in multiple arts distinctly for the arts that they are (for the purpose of preservation and lineage) but I train techniques that are influenced by two or three styles and when I spar all those styles are present and I draw from them the aspects that I find most effective for me. So in my case I do blend them together in a meaningful way.Unless I blend them together in some kind of meaningful way in my practice, I am a diversified martial artist, but not necessarily a mixed martial artist.
A quick reply, for time is limited. Your opinions are well presented.
But my opinion has never changed.
I have never been able to like, or respect MMA. I think it damages the image of Martial Arts. Damages and does nothing to help.
This comes back to whether or not you have to spar with certian moves to ready you for using them in real life. I train with guys who practice all the dirty stuff like throat strikes, groin strikes, eye gouges etc and all the things that are 'against the rules' in MMA. Now these guys obviously dont spar using these techniques but the fact they have practiced them literally thousands and thousands of times over 20 years or more leads me to believe that if they were being attacked those moves would come out and would be performed brutally. Just because they dont use them in sparring doesnt mean they cant do them effectively in my opinion. For a lot of these guys those moves would be the first thing they would rely on if defending themselves, whereas as a 'sports fighter' does not train these moves as they are not part of the ruleset so it is less likely they would be proficient in using them to defend themselves. Basically my point is, just because you dont do something in sparring doesnt mean you cant do it, providing it is practced regularly. For instance, I spar by WTF ruleset (no kicking below the belt), but I can assure you if push come to shove the first thing I will do is kick their knee out using one of the kicks Ive practiced a million times , just because I dont do it in sparring doesnt mean I cant do it.Now keep in mind that any "traditional" style that does all those likely either doesn't spar at all, or spars and competes under rules that are far more limiting then those used in MMA.
But if you are from a school where nose and ear pulls are a major part of sparring, please post some videos set to benny hill music.
A quick reply, for time is limited. Your opinions are well presented.
But my opinion has never changed.
I have never been able to like, or respect MMA. I think it damages the image of Martial Arts. Damages and does nothing to help.
but I can assure you if push come to shove the first thing I will do is kick their knee out using one of the kicks Ive practiced a million times , just because I dont do it in sparring doesnt mean I cant do it.
Now let me ask you this, in MMA kicking the knee is legal, so are you confident that it will have the effect you think it will when it very rarely does a great deal when used in full contact sparring?
Also, I can assure you that any sport fighter knows all the dirty tricks, despite being illegal in competition they still are used. In recent fights Kimbo can be seen digging a thumb into the eye in a attempt to get out of a triangle that the ref didn't catch, paul Daley was using a similar technique from the bottom of mount against Koschek. Groin kicks are a frequent occurrence, despite being illegal.
Also look at the history of MMA, it came out of vale tudo, in which none of the current rules really existed and schools did, and often still do include those in there training to some extent, although certainly not to the same extent as legal techniques. However you do have to remain aware of what the fouls are in any combat sport.
But to the real question, if you are confident that you can use techniques that exist outside of your sparring and competition rules if forced to do so, why would you assume that others, competing under a different ruleset are not capable of doing the same?[/quote]
Exactly!
The difference as I see it is that, yes, they know the dirty tricks (I dont doubt that for a second), but they dont train them or practice them over and over because they are not part of the ruleset. I 'know' how to play golf, but I do not train it everyday so I doubt I could go out and become a pro golfer, just as these guys 'know' the dirty tricks but they dont train them over and over where some arts do. I dont doubt their skill for a minute and Im sure they could easily handle themselves on the street, but they are training in a 'sport' with rules and if viewed this way I have no problems with it whatsoever, but when people base "what works and what doesnt work" on what they've seen in MMA I have a problem with it. So, in answer to your question, I am as sure as I can be that techniques that exist outside my sparring ruleset may well work because I have practiced them time and time again, I may not use them in sparring but they are something I do 4 to 5 days a week, every week. Sportsman train for what may happen in a game, a cricketer does not practice batting against under arm bowling because they cannot come accross this in a game, so they simply dont train it, just as a sports fighter is not going to spend hours and hours practicing throat strikes because it is not something they are allowed to do or have to learn to defend against.Now let me ask you this, in MMA kicking the knee is legal, so are you confident that it will have the effect you think it will when it very rarely does a great deal when used in full contact sparring?
Also, I can assure you that any sport fighter knows all the dirty tricks, despite being illegal in competition they still are used. In recent fights Kimbo can be seen digging a thumb into the eye in a attempt to get out of a triangle that the ref didn't catch, paul Daley was using a similar technique from the bottom of mount against Koschek. Groin kicks are a frequent occurrence, despite being illegal.
Also look at the history of MMA, it came out of vale tudo, in which none of the current rules really existed and schools did, and often still do include those in there training to some extent, although certainly not to the same extent as legal techniques. However you do have to remain aware of what the fouls are in any combat sport.
But to the real question, if you are confident that you can use techniques that exist outside of your sparring and competition rules if forced to do so, why would you assume that others, competing under a different ruleset are not capable of doing the same?[/quote]
Exactly!
but when people base "what works and what doesnt work" on what they've seen in MMA I have a problem with it.
The difference as I see it is that, yes, they know the dirty tricks (I dont doubt that for a second), but they dont train them or practice them over and over because they are not part of the ruleset. I 'know' how to play golf, but I do not train it everyday so I doubt I could go out and become a pro golfer, just as these guys 'know' the dirty tricks but they dont train them over and over where some arts do. I dont doubt their skill for a minute and Im sure they could easily handle themselves on the street, but they are training in a 'sport' with rules and if viewed this way I have no problems with it whatsoever, but when people base "what works and what doesnt work" on what they've seen in MMA I have a problem with it. So, in answer to your question, I am as sure as I can be that techniques that exist outside my sparring ruleset may well work because I have practiced them time and time again, I may not use them in sparring but they are something I do 4 to 5 days a week, every week. Sportsman train for what may happen in a game, a cricketer does not practice batting against under arm bowling because they cannot come accross this in a game, so they simply dont train it, just as a sports fighter is not going to spend hours and hours practicing throat strikes because it is not something they are allowed to do or have to learn to defend against.
I think what people are overlooking is that there are very few professional MMA fighters, there are many who fight pro rules but they don't earn their living fighting so don't train MMA day in day out, many, like the fighters at our club also train SD. A lot of fighters I know train SD with people like Geoff Thompson, his seminars and courses are very popular here. Karl Tanswell as well as training MMA fighters is well known for his SD training. One of our fighters recently gained his instructor certificate in Krav Maga. Many fighters work as doormen, police offciers, or are in the military, many do jobs where self defence is important, such as social work, teaching, security etc who fight.
I know only of literally five pro fighters here who do nothing but train, everyone else can't spend hours and hours training every day, most of them are also TMA people and will train a wide variety of techniques. Also most fighters other than the top guys will only fight a couple of times a year if that so the danger of only being able to fight in the cage/ring is much less likely. Most guys ( and girls) I know are more than able to step out of the rule mind set into a 'street' mind where they can defend themselves perfectly well. I guess most of you have seen the two Welsh guys in drag more than defending themselves on the You Tube clip.
Another good point, and personally, I feel the same way. As another example: we talk about the elbow to the back against a double leg. The TMA guys feel its a valid tech, the MMA guys disagree. Yet in that Kaju show, we saw a very effective elbow to the back of Jimmy.
Quite true. I think MMA is now suffering the same problems from 'exposure' that TMA's have suffered for years. Its like people who watch some olympic tkd sparring and then say "tkd guys cant punch, all they do is kick and they fight with their guard down", its not true but people can only go by what they see on the television if they dont actually participate in the MA. Now, all MMA fighters are lumped together because of what people see on the UFC on the television. Unfortunately it goes with the territory.I think what people are overlooking is that there are very few professional MMA fighters, there are many who fight pro rules but they don't earn their living fighting so don't train MMA day in day out, many, like the fighters at our club also train SD. A lot of fighters I know train SD with people like Geoff Thompson, his seminars and courses are very popular here. Karl Tanswell as well as training MMA fighters is well known for his SD training. One of our fighters recently gained his instructor certificate in Krav Maga. Many fighters work as doormen, police offciers, or are in the military, many do jobs where self defence is important, such as social work, teaching, security etc who fight.
I know only of literally five pro fighters here who do nothing but train, everyone else can't spend hours and hours training every day, most of them are also TMA people and will train a wide variety of techniques. Also most fighters other than the top guys will only fight a couple of times a year if that so the danger of only being able to fight in the cage/ring is much less likely. Most guys ( and girls) I know are more than able to step out of the rule mind set into a 'street' mind where they can defend themselves perfectly well. I guess most of you have seen the two Welsh guys in drag more than defending themselves on the You Tube clip.
The difference as I see it is that, yes, they know the dirty tricks (I dont doubt that for a second), but they dont train them or practice them over and over because they are not part of the ruleset. I 'know' how to play golf, but I do not train it everyday so I doubt I could go out and become a pro golfer, just as these guys 'know' the dirty tricks but they dont train them over and over where some arts do. I dont doubt their skill for a minute and Im sure they could easily handle themselves on the street, but they are training in a 'sport' with rules and if viewed this way I have no problems with it whatsoever, but when people base "what works and what doesnt work" on what they've seen in MMA I have a problem with it. So, in answer to your question, I am as sure as I can be that techniques that exist outside my sparring ruleset may well work because I have practiced them time and time again, I may not use them in sparring but they are something I do 4 to 5 days a week, every week. Sportsman train for what may happen in a game, a cricketer does not practice batting against under arm bowling because they cannot come accross this in a game, so they simply dont train it, just as a sports fighter is not going to spend hours and hours practicing throat strikes because it is not something they are allowed to do or have to learn to defend against.
Great points. If a MMA practicianer trained those types of technques and did some training modified for the street i.e. Differnt body positioning and stancing, accounting for the pressence of a blade (No more double leg takedowns!) an enemy who will try to rip or bite off an ear or finger (I saw a guy bite of another mans lip once.) and some other considerations and he will be just fine for the street. I know Gregg Jackson teaches his fighters about these things, it be safe to assume others do as well.
The average MMA fighter stance leaves his testicles open like a speed bag because no one is suppossed to kick him there, so he uses stances that work better for the ruleset. That is smart for his sport, could be the end in the street.
And before I get the usual MMA Fanboy, well a kick to the groin, a gouge of the eyes ect probably wont stop a determined fighter, how many MMA fights have been stopped because of an inadvertent eye poke or gouge? 2 that I have seen. How many times you see a fighter need a few minutes after a knee to the balls? a few that I have seen.
No imagine someone targets your eyes and groin and it's someone who has practiced and drilled these techniques and is out to end you.
A MMA fighter (Hobbyist, Amatuer or semi Pro) would do well to spend maybe 20-30% of his time training for the street and then I would not want to fight him.
A traiditional or Combat martial Artist would do well making sure he did some non cooperative and semi co operative light to full contact sparring.
See both camps have much to offer, they are bothg right and wrong. Work together and then they can both be right.
Even with the negaitves, which to me are way more about idiotic internet fanboys and their underinformed opinions holding MMA up as the be all end all of fighting than anything the ighters themselves do, MMA is a great sport and has much to offer the rest of the MA community.
Shugyo!
The average MMA fighter stance leaves his testicles open like a speed bag because no one is suppossed to kick him there, so he uses stances that work better for the ruleset. That is smart for his sport, could be the end in the street.
Good point in my opinion. The MMA fighter adapts to the rules of the organization he fights under for advantage. Training like this over a period of years could definitely lead to some habits that may be counterproductive in the street. Not to say they could not be reconciled. In contrast, most traditional martial artists would be at a disadvantage in a cage match because of that very same rule set and would need to adapt to the circumstance. With the different training goals will come habits that will either help or hinder in a given situation. However all habits can be broken or created with practice and repetition so the advanced MMA fighter that cross trains may be able to adapt to his environment very quickly.
Great points. If a MMA practicianer trained those types of technques and did some training modified for the street i.e. Differnt body positioning and stancing, accounting for the pressence of a blade (No more double leg takedowns!) an enemy who will try to rip or bite off an ear or finger (I saw a guy bite of another mans lip once.) and some other considerations and he will be just fine for the street. I know Gregg Jackson teaches his fighters about these things, it be safe to assume others do as well.
The average MMA fighter stance leaves his testicles open like a speed bag because no one is suppossed to kick him there, so he uses stances that work better for the ruleset. That is smart for his sport, could be the end in the street.
And before I get the usual MMA Fanboy, well a kick to the groin, a gouge of the eyes ect probably wont stop a determined fighter, how many MMA fights have been stopped because of an inadvertent eye poke or gouge? 2 that I have seen. How many times you see a fighter need a few minutes after a knee to the balls? a few that I have seen.
No imagine someone targets your eyes and groin and it's someone who has practiced and drilled these techniques and is out to end you.
A MMA fighter (Hobbyist, Amatuer or semi Pro) would do well to spend maybe 20-30% of his time training for the street and then I would not want to fight him.
A traiditional or Combat martial Artist would do well making sure he did some non cooperative and semi co operative light to full contact sparring.
See both camps have much to offer, they are bothg right and wrong. Work together and then they can both be right.
Even with the negaitves, which to me are way more about idiotic internet fanboys and their underinformed opinions holding MMA up as the be all end all of fighting than anything the ighters themselves do, MMA is a great sport and has much to offer the rest of the MA community.
Shugyo!
Your quote has me saying what was actually said by someone else!!
MMA rules say you have 5 minutes to recover from a kick to the groin, of course personally I've never found being kicked in the nuts a problem rofl!
However most men will stand 'defensively' in any situation which may endanger their precious bits.
Totally on a tangent, when a fighter is kicked in the groin there is this sussuration of noise all around the spectators, even the ref winces. there's two separate noises, a gasp from all the males watching and a giggle from all the women.