glad2bhere
Master Black Belt
I recently posted this response in adiscussion and wondered how people felt about this observation. The introduction of modifications (or not) to what we do is always a hot topic.
"........
However, it is rather common for a student of Korean traditions at some particular level to introduce modifications to the material imparted to him, which creates a kind of quandary. On one hand the student must replicate what has been passed to him as a tradition, honoring the teacher as he does. On the other hand Korean culture requires that a person remain eminently pragmatic and adaptable to current circumstances which are arguably a mainstay of the Korean culture from time immemorial. The solution seems to be this odd practice of quietly introducing modification and when these are identified attributing the modifications to the last teacher who is often deceased. I believe the Japanese are a bit "neater" about it as they have the "Ha" or "branch" provision in their culture that allows for this organizationally. The Koreans seem to simply start up a new organization if the KMA population don't swallow this approach and express their modifications that way. As you say, though, this last option tends to undermine the authenticity of the art and opens the door to undermining the arts very existence.
....."
Thoughts?
Best Wishes,
Bruce
"........
However, it is rather common for a student of Korean traditions at some particular level to introduce modifications to the material imparted to him, which creates a kind of quandary. On one hand the student must replicate what has been passed to him as a tradition, honoring the teacher as he does. On the other hand Korean culture requires that a person remain eminently pragmatic and adaptable to current circumstances which are arguably a mainstay of the Korean culture from time immemorial. The solution seems to be this odd practice of quietly introducing modification and when these are identified attributing the modifications to the last teacher who is often deceased. I believe the Japanese are a bit "neater" about it as they have the "Ha" or "branch" provision in their culture that allows for this organizationally. The Koreans seem to simply start up a new organization if the KMA population don't swallow this approach and express their modifications that way. As you say, though, this last option tends to undermine the authenticity of the art and opens the door to undermining the arts very existence.
....."
Thoughts?
Best Wishes,
Bruce
