Im pretty sure that whether youre learning for sport, or for combatives, thats the same.
I will, however, disagree with taking hundreds of strikes - But, i suspect you were exaggerating, and that it just didnt translate too well into text.
My mistake, I meant both sides throwing hundreds of strikes in a competition fight. Not necessarily landing hundreds of clean strikes, nor landing that many at all.
All you need to do is bounce the other guys head off the ground.
If only it were that easy I've had a guy go into street mode during hard sparring/prepping for a fight....and in the clinch, he grabbed my head and slammed the back of it into the bare concrete wall (our gym is a converted industrial warehouse). He was a fighter from an affiliate gym and this was the first time I was sparring him. I was beating him really bad right before this, and for many rounds so I guess he got frustrated and went into survival mode. Luckily, I had headgear on. It rung my bell, but didn't stop the fight. Needless to say, I was out for blood right after that and he started running. The bell rang and saved him. After that he avoided me the whole night.
Why not just KO them with one punch, like a ring fighting champ?
Why should I when I have a GUN with 10 rounds of hollowpoints, 1-2 spare mags + 2 knives? Just because I enjoy trying to KO people in the ring....you can't seem to accept the fact that I'm also proficient in the streets, bouncing at clubs, etc.
Combatives tend to involve the use of weapons. Im glad we can agree on why.
OK, but I can use weapons too. I'm almost always going to have a gun on me in States that allows conceal carry and reciprocates my permit. And I will certainly have a knife. Sparring with a rubber knife, I've already proven to myself that I can slash the hell out of these traditional Jujutsu sensei's who's main gig is such SD training with weapons. One is a 2nd dan and the other is a brown belt and both are active cops. And yes, they can fight. Just that when sparring with a rubber knife, they get slashed at least 8-10 times before they can grab me. Sometimes they even clinch me in a hug but misses my knife hand....and I'm there fake stabbing them profusely as we both laugh. And all of my knife fighting skills is mostly just using my skills as an MMA fighter....boxing with a knife + footwork + agility, speed, etc.
And here, we agree, sort of. Its almost like your reasoning is great, but your conclusions are a bit peculiar.
Im of the view that technique means much less than method. By that i mean, technique = push off the ground with the back foot, pull with the front foot, drop your weight, extend your rear knee, pivot on your feet, pivot on your hip, rotate your torso and your shoulder, engage your arm into the punch. Method = Punch the other guy in the face.
And im inclined to think that those abilities can come more from experience in hitting other people with your fists, i.e. sparring. I also think that that only teaches you that particular skill in a limited manner.
Put a knife in an experienced Boxer's hand. Who do you think is going to be faster in a knife fight? A trained Boxer who throws thousands of punches a week, training footwork, agility, endurance, reflex, etc... or someone who doesn't?
And if there's anything that can be learned from fighting knife-on-knife....it's just don't do it. The winner is the guy who's going to die latter in the hospital.
The average engagement takes place for much further away than you could possibly need unarmed work, certainly. But that doesnt mean the fighter isnt strong, fit, and mentally willing to go for you. He may not be as experienced, but even the experienced can be taken down by someone whos never even been in a fight. And it happens.
I don't doubt this at all. I was just trying to KO this big Brazilian gorilla just last week in 4 rounds of sparring. He was much bigger than me. I hit him with at least 4 solid shots to the face with looping overhand rights, and it didn't put him down. It rattled his confidence though. We both had headgear on, so that took off some damage. He was experienced too. On the ground, he would have been deadmeat as I've got over 2 years over him in BJJ. But size certainly does matter, as well as someone's desire to live. But I go through this much more often compared to someone who hardly spars for KO's...as most of my hard sparring is vs. guys my level. Then there are those who can whoop me, which tests all of my reactions, endurance and thresholds in moments of panic, fear, pain, confusion, etc.
MMA makes you better at striking, ill certainly agree. Im not disputing that. But like combatives, theyre often limited in what they teach. In MMA, if you get someone in an armbar, can you stomp on the side of their head? No. Can the person DOING MMA do that? Certainly. And so could anyone else who suddenly thought, in a real fight of any sort, "Hey, i could stomp on his head from here."
Technique < Quality of Training, is pretty much what im getting at. For my opinion on sports vs combatives, read my original reply.
A lot of people seems to think that MMA fighters are somehow forced to abide by MMA rules when they're fighting in the streets or on the battlefield of a war....like there's some kind of chip, implanted in an MMA fighter's head or something.
I don't really need someone to teach me how to head stomp nor soccer kick some guy unconscious on the ground that I just KO'ed on the battlefield, should I want to crush his skull in with my boots and kill him. It will just come automatically. Just think about it.....a full time fighter's goal in life is to knock people the F out or to hurt their opponent so bad that they quit. Beating your training partner down and watching him cower in fear and respecting you....feels soooooo good. It's a great feeling. Who's going to more likely do better in a H2H battlefield or street situation?