-------------------------
On wing Chun and history. books and you tube
Competent scholarly historians have been under involved in dealing with Chinese martial arts. Specially true for wing chun which is full of self serving lineage stories.
But the search for history is not irrelevant.. One has to have a sense of the subject, of reliable, translations and watching out for metaphors rather than one to one dictionary definitions.
There is no question that Ip Man has made the singular and greatest contribution in making the world aware of wing chun, Yet he did not write a book about wing chun or it’s “history”.. A brief statement on ng mui, yim wing chun two key boat people and leing jan, chan wa shun and then the magazine interview where he mentions the role of Leung Bik in his training. There are many reports on his conversations and his encounters
It was my great good fortune to be living in Tucson. And beginning my wing chun journey with Sifu Augustine Fong, attending Ho Kam Ming seminars in Arizona and taking lessons from him in Canada..
There is no good systematic written history of wing chun. Finding a decent and knowledgeable teacher and learning how to learn is much better than learning from books or the you tube.
A case in point is the relatively recently published book-”The Creation of Wing Chun”by Benjamin Judkins and Jon Nielson.Half the book involves a Cook’s tour of the Southern Chinese Martial arts-too general to shed muchlight on the depth of wing chun..The second half deals with “contemporary’ wing chun- no real insight on principles or concepts and is based on a few self serving interviews with people like Hawkins Cheung. Yet the search for history is not unimportant because it can give chance insights in addition to training and development.