Whats the difference between a bow hunter and an Olympic archer?
*deadpan*
Moose Knuckle?
(ducks for cover)
:redcaptur
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Whats the difference between a bow hunter and an Olympic archer?
I just read one blog article that put self defense as the opposite polar of the martial art.
He quoted the mind set in here as the point of argument.
a self defense, is an art to free from things that harmful to oneself.
while a martial art, is the art of war...
here the quote from Rory Miller's Meditation on Violence:
ĀSelf defense is about recovery from stupidity or bad luck, from finding yourself in a position you would have given almost anything to prevent.
It is better to avoid than to run; better to run than to de-escalate; better to de-escalate than to fight; better to fight than to die. The very essence of self-defense is a thin list of things that might get you out alive when you are already screwed.Ā
Hmm… can you explain how the foundation of Hozoin Ryu is self defence? Or Owari Kan Ryu? How about Morishige Ryu? Hyoho Niten Ichi Ryu?
My point is that, no, the foundation of all martial arts is not self defence… not even the majority… they really are quite removed...
I am not familiar with any of the styles that you mentioned, so all I have to go by is Googling them. And I see that they are all martial arts of some type, and are therefore based on self-defense.
What is the underlying foundation of any martial art? I think it is this: prevent someone else from harming you. Most of the time, that is oriented toward block and counter, or evade and counter, but every once in a while, we'll encounter a situation where the best defense is a good offense. And if that means learning how to stick someone with a spear before they can stick you, or something similar, then so be it.
I am not familiar with any of the styles that you mentioned, so all I have to go by is Googling them. And I see that they are all martial arts of some type, and are therefore based on self-defence.
What is the underlying foundation of any martial art?
I think it is this: prevent someone else from harming you.
Most of the time, that is oriented toward block and counter, or evade and counter, but every once in a while, we'll encounter a situation where the best defense is a good offense. And if that means learning how to stick someone with a spear before they can stick you, or something similar, then so be it.
It is a really fine line between a martial art for self defence and a martial art to see who is the biggest dog in the room. Quite often a martial art is meant to handle both.
And one originates from another and then originates from that.
Jousting is learning how to stick someone with a spear. But is it battlefield or sport?
And before we get too semantic about the meanings of words. They change to fit current circumstances.
See, that's the issueĀ none of the systems I named are based on self defenceĀ and they are hardly unique in that either.
There is noneĀ at least, there is no single underlying foundation that is equally applicable across the vast range of approaches that are classed as "martial arts".
Nope, not always. In fact, not even commonly. It's a commonly held belief, but when looked at objectively, it falls rather short in the light of reality.
That's a particular tactical application, and really isn't much to do with "the foundation of martial arts", when it comes down to it. But, for the record, no, that's not anything to do with self defence (in the sojutsu hypothetical you're giving).
Hmm. No, it isn't, and no, they aren't.
No. They're kinda pretty opposite to each other.
Well, no, jousting isn't just "learning how to stick someone with a spear" to begin withĀ but, realistically, it's sport. It's not battlefield kinda by definition. It originated as a training form for some aspects or skills on the battlefield, but jousting itself is very removed, and is a completely different context.
No sport is battlefield battlefield is sport on many occasions.
Soldiers doing sport on the battlefield.
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hXTNUHh9vmU
And for the battle field.
MMA in the US Military: Soldier Survival Training | POW! Mixed Martial Arts & Fitness
And in battle.
Diggers defend killer Commando Sergeant Paul Cale
MMA In the Military | *FIGHT! Magazine ? Archives
But otherwise a huge difference?
Makes me think about the Ancient Greeks and their "games". Many of them were combat sports that tested skills they took right from the battlefield.
Combat sport - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Sent from my Kindle Fire using Tapatalk 2
In self defense,we think of doing "to" our opponent just as they are trying to do something "to" us. The goal for us is to gain control of our opponent. In traditional martial arts and sport fighting the mentality is usually that of sparring "with" or fighting "with" someone else.
Unless we are talking about a social setting where some friend or relative had had to much alcohol. Then restraint until they see reason may be indicated. On the street, no way. And a stomp on the ankle as you leave them on the ground is a nice finishing touch.If your goal in self defense is "to gain control of" your opponent -- what are you going to do with them once you've controlled them?
As a LEO, my goal is absolutely to restrain and control the subject in order to arrest them. But for a private citizen? Nope, their goal should be to deal with the initial attack, do sufficient damage to deter pursuit, and escape. I once saw a beautiful "self defense" technique. It was really great, though rather complicated. Oh, and it ended in an arm bar. Which is nice... if you want to stand there indefinitely holding someone who tried to hurt you. And is probably now more than slightly enraged...
We'll have to agree to disagree on this.
I don't know if the story of Bodidharma teaching the Shaolin monks is factually true or not, but let's assume that it is. What was he teaching them? Martial arts so that they could defend themselves from robbers as they roamed the countryside.
Perhaps I am misreading your interpretation, Mr. Parker, but it seems to me that you are saying that if there is an offensive element of some sort, then it is not self-defense. If that is the case, then by your definition, there is no such thing as self-defense if you ever strike your opponent in any manner. Am I totally off base here?
To me, it is quite simple.
Self defence is the art of not getting your head kicked in, and martial arts will help to facilitate that.
Does it need to be more complex than that?
I saw some posts about the military practicing such things, and it seemed to the theme that this is secondary. Maybe, but I happen to know that certain sections of British military take hand to hand combat extremely seriously. Perhaps google search 'para milling', to see the Parachute regiment just hitting each other to train in the art of taking a punch. The combatants are not allow to block or counter, they just have to hit and be hit. Or theres our Royal Marines with their combat. Tell me this isn't martial arts.
Royal Marine Commandos- HAND TO HAND COMBAT - YouTube
No sport is battlefield battlefield is sport on many occasions.
Soldiers doing sport on the battlefield.
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hXTNUHh9vmU
And for the battle field.
MMA in the US Military: Soldier Survival Training | POW! Mixed Martial Arts & Fitness
But otherwise a huge difference?
Makes me think about the Ancient Greeks and their "games". Many of them were combat sports that tested skills they took right from the battlefield.
Combat sport - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jujitsu. Sport self defence martial art. Frankly who knows where one starts and the other stops.
Edith Margaret Garrud - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Bartitsu a mixed martial art.
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=t7aKdU96JuA
Muay Thai as a battlefield/self defence/sport.
muay thai History | muay thai
In self defense,we think of doing "to" our opponent just as they are trying to do something "to" us. The goal for us is to gain control of our opponent. In traditional martial arts and sport fighting the mentality is usually that of sparring "with" or fighting "with" someone else.
I dropped a guy over the weekend. Arm barred him until he cried and then let his friends take him away. Which they did. You don't have to murder death kill everybody you get into contact with.
My pitch being I will let him go this time but if he goes for round two I will drop him on his head.