To continue with that analogy, Training striking on a heavy bag, is like making love to one of these:
I'm sorry, but this whole "Anti-Grappling" thing horrifies me
- Thread starter Marnetmar
- Start date
To continue with that analogy, Training striking on a heavy bag, is like making love to one of these:
ShotoNoob
Master Black Belt
|
Well now I don't feel so bad about much of the criticisms leveled @ me. Given my total absence of experience where one such as you brings to the table...
Hanzou
Grandmaster
Hanzou
Grandmaster
What's the skill level of my opponent in this theory? Am I dealing with a highly skilled grappler, or just some clown in the street?
Thing is, lay and pray and stacking only works on a skilled Bjj player if you're also a highly skilled grappler with an amazing top game and sub defense. Bjj is literally designed to deal with that sort of thing with its guard sweeps and it's various guard chokes and locks. Further, Bjj players should be getting trained to deal with strikes while in guard. I was always trained that way because my academy(ies) were always old school Gracie academies.
The problem is that you're looking at this through the prism of someone who is trained to directly counter a highly skilled guard. The vast majority of people have absolutely no idea how to do that. And those that do are almost always equivalent to purple to black belt Bjj practitioners themselves.
If you need any evidence of this, just view that Krav Maga vid I posted where the guy opens himself up to numerous submissions and sweeps without even realizing it. He has no idea how the guard works at all, yet he made a video on how to stop it.
So yeah, if I'm dealing with a MMA guy who is bigger, stronger, and just as skilled as I am, I'm in a lot of trouble. If I'm dealing with that Krav Maga guy, I'll be just fine.
Last edited:
drop bear
Sr. Grandmaster
If I can handle the skilled guy. The unskilled guy will handle himself.
But I think I mentioned that for the most part the anti grappler does not have the depth of knowledge that a bjj guy has. He is running very lean on techniques when it comes to ground work. So the skill level is always a lot closer than a dedicated bjjer.
It's not ignored. I was taught this aspect some 20 years ago. We were taught to deal with shoulder throws, hip throws, waist clenches.....
drop bear
Sr. Grandmaster
What method were you taught?
Vajramusti
Master Black Belt
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
For me, good wing chun body dynamics and wing chun principles carries me far. My late good Alaskan Malamute could handle a great dane when standing on two feet and didn't have to become a fish in order to swim
in rivers and lakes.
And honor to Ip man for his legacy on Father's day.
IMO, the most effective counters are:
1. shoulder throw - "摘(Zai) – helmet removing",
2. hip throw - "崩(Beng) - elbow cracking",
3. waist clenches - "抹(Mo) - eyebrow wiping".
Here is the "摘(Zai) – helmet removing". In order to do this properly, the line between your feet and the line between your opponent's feet should be in a 90 degree angle.
Since this is an "anti-grappling" thread, it may be interested to discuss the WC solutions for these.
Last edited:
- Wrestlers don't talk much about ground game,Don't forget, we Bjj guys throw just like the Judo and Wrestler guys.
- BJJ guys don't talk much about throw.
This is understandable. But from the "anti-grappling" point of view, both issues should be addressed.
I agree. An attack, whether it be striking or grappling of some sort, is simply placing some form of pressure on the body.
If WC teaches anything, it's dealing with pressures placed on the body.
Vajramusti
Master Black Belt
IMO, the most effective counters are:
1. shoulder throw - "摘(Zai) – helmet removing",
2. hip throw - "崩(Beng) - elbow cracking",
3. waist clenches - "抹(Mo) - eyebrow wiping".
Here is the "摘(Zai) – helmet removing". In order to do this properly, the line between your feet and the line between your opponent's feet should be in a 90 degree angle.
---------------------------------------------------------
I operate from my wing chun stance and footwork-and don't depend on fixed techniques with fixed names.
Can do 1, 2 or 3 with wing chun dynamics
Since this is an "anti-grappling" thread, it may be interested to discuss the WC solutions for these.
Shai Hulud
Purple Belt
The takedowns are much more fun!
For anti-grappling, there is no single master key that can open all locks. You have to "find the right key to open the right lock". Of course you can use hammer to smash on a lock and open it. It may take more force than you really need. With the right key, you can open your lock with very little effort. In other words, the "anti-grappling" will require a set of "special skills" that you need to train no matter what style that you may come from.
For example, when your opponent applies "leg lift (Uchi Mata)" on you, the only best counter is to "ride on". You try to
- borrow your opponent's lifting force,
- jump on his back, and
- use your weight to crash him all the way down onto the ground.
Since this "ride on" skill will require a lot of training (otherwise you won't be able to respond to your opponent's throw on time), there is no "short cut" for "anti-grappling".
For example, when your opponent applies "leg lift (Uchi Mata)" on you, the only best counter is to "ride on". You try to
- borrow your opponent's lifting force,
- jump on his back, and
- use your weight to crash him all the way down onto the ground.
Since this "ride on" skill will require a lot of training (otherwise you won't be able to respond to your opponent's throw on time), there is no "short cut" for "anti-grappling".
Last edited:
Jake104
Black Belt
Good post! The real skill is learning how to recognize and react before the throw, takedown or choke gets to the point of no return. Obviously it's easier said than done. There are counter techniques that work or it can be as simple as having really good timing and sensitivity. Both go hand and hand and both require quite a bit of training. You ask for the WC point of view? That's mine. Simple.For anti-grappling, there is no single master key that can open all locks. You have to "find the right key to open the right lock". Of course you can use hammer to smash on a lock and open it. It may take more force than you really need. With the right key, you can open your lock with very little effort. In other words, the "anti-grappling" will require a set of "special skills" that you need to train no matter what style that you may come from.
For example, when your opponent applies "leg lift (Uchi Mata)" on you, the only best counter is to "ride on". You try to
- borrow your opponent's lifting force,
- jump on his back, and
- use your weight to crash him all the way down onto the ground.
Since this "ride on" skill will require a lot of training (otherwise you won't be able to respond to your opponent's throw on time), there is no "short cut" for "anti-grappling".
drop bear
Sr. Grandmaster
Somewhere in this thread I did mention ways to give yourself a bit more time.
That is part of the equation. Otherwise you have to always be significantly better than the guy you are fighting. Which is not always possible.
Jake104
Black Belt
I agree. It's all about being a step or two ahead of the opponent. There are tricks or safeguards to always be.
JohnnyEnglish
Green Belt
Cruel to see how they are not even able to have a proper head-cover up with their hands. Every kickboxer could knock them out with an aimed punch to the nose.
