I just couldn't resist putting my two cents in.
Let me preface my post by first stating that I am not martial arts expert. Nor do I profess to be the toughest guy this side of the Mississippi. I'm a student that became aware of things that I had to work on to be the best that I can be as a martial artist, and be able to defend myself and my loved ones if necessary.
I live in NYC, and I have seen A LOT of people, including my former self, develop a false sense of security in their skills despite the fact that they never tested themselves or their complex techniques in the ring and/or on the mat.
First of all, in regards to streetfighting, most 'street fights' happen where alcohol (and maybe drugs) are in abundance like dance clubs, bars, and concerts.
If you stay alert and sober, and make a few lifestyle changes, and use your GOD-given common sense, you will avoid most 'street fights.'
A lot of people say that real fighting includes eye pokes, biting, head butts, etc.
I have a question for those who don't want to bother with sport fighting because that isn't 'real fighting'...
If you can't punch someone in the face with a 14oz glove, what in the heck makes you think that you can poke them in the eye?
'Sports' like Western Boxing, Kickboxing (in all its forms), and wrestling (in all its forms) help you develop timing, distancing, footwork, endurance, mental toughness, and the ability to "take a licking and keep on ticking" while under fire (i.e. someone is trying to kick your butt).
When you are in a "too deadly to spar" martial art, your pulling your punches and hitting intentionally off target will come back to haunt you. That is what will be programmed into you muscle memory. Hey, you're going to fight the way you train and when you get into a real fight, and your punches and kicks fall short of their target, you very well may have blown your only chance and you could be in deep doo-doo.
Let's be real here, NO ONE is going to just let you walk up to them and apply a joint lock, a throw, or strike them.
A non-cooperative opponent keeps you honest to yourself about what you need to work on, and what is and isn't effective.
Great men like the founder of Judo, Jigoro Kano, took up the martial arts to strengthen his body - to become tougher. And he realized that the only way you can test your technique and conditioning is to actually go against a non-cooperative opponent - NOT AN UKE/COOPERATIVE PARTNER! Thus the advent of what is called "Randori."
Famous Karateka, Mas Oyama is well-known because and his Kyokushin Karate style and its offshoots like Seido Karate are known as "knockout karate." Knocking out who? A non-cooperative, agressive, determined opponent, that is who.
If you are a martial artist, you need to hit some, and get hit some.
How are you going to know what works and doesn't work? Of course everything works against an uke, but the ring and/or the mat will be the laboratory in which you can test technique and learn new things.
Yeah, okay....
Keep on planning to poke a Boxer/Kickboxer or grappler in the eye or kick him in the groin. All of the "too deadly to spar" types always have a great plan - UNTIL THEY GET HIT!
In regards to multiple opponents, you must have superior endurance and you have to be use to being hit - because you will be hit. You have to stick and move...and then RUN! Same thing with weapons. I've seen people stabbed and shanked and if you think that you will have time to stand toe-to-toe with a determined attacker and work you technique and not be cut, you are very mistaken.
Remember, everything works in the dojo and at martial arts demos. If you want to see what will not work, take a field trip to your a popular bar or club during college spring break when excess testosterone is floating around.
"The more you sweat during peace, the less you will bleed in war." - Sun Tzu
Respectfully,
Tyrone Turner
"Zujitsuka"
Queens, NY
http://www.tyroneturner.com