Hanzou
Grandmaster
- Joined
- Sep 29, 2013
- Messages
- 6,770
- Reaction score
- 1,330
Not really. The story goes that Kano couldn't defeat one man at the tenshin shinyo ryu dojo he was studying at-apparently, he was quite large for a Japanese. Kano consulted a sumo wrestler, several other people, and found a technique in a book on western wrestling he thought might work, the fireman's carry. The fact that similar techniques existed-independent of "outside influence"(see previous post in re: human articulation and technique development)-in medieval European martial arts, Indian martial arts, sumo,. as well as several Japanese koryu jujutsu ryuha, including tenshin shinyo ryu, the very style Kano was studying doesn't make the story doubtful-but it does make the "influence" doubtful, and it is, as far as I can recall, the only place where he makes any mention of western wrestling prior to the development of judo. Later on, of course, as it became a sport, western wrestling had an influence on judo, especially (as I've said elsewhere) in the development of weight classes-these were, of course, post WWII developments-though, perhaps, he knew something of scholastic wrestling as an educator, and modeled some of judos structure on this-who can say? He certainly didn't-in fact, while he studied western wrestling and boxing, he made some rather negative comments on the (later) influence of western wrestling on judo randori...
Whether or not Kano was influenced by western wrestling is pretty irrelevant to the overall point; Judo has been influenced by western wrestling throughout its history and its still Judo. Please point out the classical Kung Fu or Karate style that has been influenced by Western Boxing or Wrestling and has still maintained its identity. You won't find one.
Further, you can't point to Judo and say that it's an example of classical Japanese Jujutsu in MMA. Just like you can't point to Sanshou and say that its an example of classical Kung fu in MMA.
Anyway, this discussion has run its course. Feel free to have the last word.