First, a thanks to the definition of "sculpting" provided above by Xue. I really think if we all would really think about what the other guy is trying to say rather than obsessing about how we personally believe a word should be used, a lot of needless argumentation could be eliminated.
As for "sculpting", I earned and MFA in the field, and I think of it as using addition, subtraction, manipulation (modeling) or substitution (casting) to create a three-dimensional form as a work of art (ie for purely
aesthetic as compared to functional reasons). Bodybuilding certainly fits this traditional definition. The human body is literally sculpted through addititive (hypertrophy) and subtractive (cutting) methods to achieve a particular
aesthetic ideal. I believe the point that Steve BJJ was making was simply that the peculiar aesthetic of bodybuilding only loosely approximates the functional form of champion fighters like Couture. In fact, pursuing a bodybuilder's
aesthetic objectives is not the most direct path to a functional fighting physique.
I feel that strength training can be very beneficial to a MAist. However, it is important to maintain your flexibility as you gain muscle... In a nutshell. Do your strength training. Throw in some pliometrics for explosiveness. Maintain your flexibility. My .02 Scott
I really think the role of "strong-man" stuff depends on the art you practice and the goals you want to achieve. Referencing the quote above, it can be a a challenge to stay light, quick and flexible while pursuing a weight training regimen, especially if you are driven to bulk-up. I practice Wing Chun and also enjoy lifting. The two do not easily co-exist. For WC we need light, elastic strength and
upper body flexibility. The fact that many bodybuilder types can kick high or do splits says nothing to the issue of upper-body flexibility and range of movement issues. If your chest is huge, it's physically impossible to put your elbow on centerline. Or if your lats are like slabs of beef, try doing double rear gum-sau (both arms extended straight back behind you... no can do!) If you have massive biceps, doing hundreds of quick, snapping chain-punches will be as hard as driving with the brakes on. And try doing a hour of chi-sau with arms that weigh a ton. Good Lord... pure agony! And your chi-sau will stink besides. So I'm cutting back on my weights a bit, going for a bit more time with bodyweight, core and cardio. while I try to find a
functional balance.