Stationary leading rollback

[Kung Fu Wang]

I saw a match from a full contact tournament in Taiwan, it’s a long time ago I saw that vid but I remember one of the combatant holding the characteristic Bagua pose trying circle walk his opponent, attacks and defense were no better than that shown in the 1954 Macau gongfu masters fight.

This video?

 

[windwalker099]

I can agree that Ralston might not hav found the essence of the arts in his learning Chinese martial arts, it seem he didn’t hang on to long to get to any depth in the TCM, had to take a “short cut” training in some regular boxing gym to get it, something like that

wow,,short cut

ok
Guess you'er not going to do any research to his background or anything..
Maybe a little before your time as well as some others..

 

[windwalker099]

This video?

Do they ?
At what level ?

A problem with looking at videos of those claiming to represent a particular style or method.

"He Jinbao now teaches Yin Style Baguazhang at
my kungfu brother's MMA academy in Beijing alongside Brazillian Jiu-Jitsu
and Muay Thai Top team coaches."

 

[Same Trick]

This video?

“i remember back when I still had YouTube at hands”

It could be, but as I say, I can’t see YouTube

 

[Same Trick]

Your guess?

Might try reading what happened to those in the match.

Not here to defend his work, or history.
He was well-known in the 1970s, found his work interesting—aligning with my own thoughts and experiences.

About his 1978 world championship win, the bio on him that I linked to in this thread just mention a Korean opponent that got so scared watching Ralston doing warmups he decided to not fight in the tournament.



The bio mentions Ralston studied a lot of martial arts… , but only explains somewhat in depth how he learned horse riding and reading zen books. Following the timeline of his studies with martial arts teachers he seems to have stayed with them for just some 1-2 years, however the bio mentions Ralston discovered things by himself around in his later teenage that made him sort of a martial.arts genius .

Some snippet-

At the judo/jujutsu school he was a 4kyu student he coached senior students for their Dan gradings.

Without any previous experience in striking methods and just after one year of karate practice he beat all the Dan grades in the karate dojo.

 

[Same Trick]

This central state is not geometrically defined—it is not the central axis, the center of gravity, the
dantian, or any other specific point. Rather, it is a state of internal equilibrium—a balance of
internal energy (nei jin)."

This I would say is what in sports is called being in the zone.
However in TCM especially the internal such the practice is specifically geared to harness it, example - correctly practice of XYQ basic santi posture is to harness it

 

[Holmejr]

How does the shang shou version of this differs from the FMA version of this. One FMA philosophy is, “better to go to the hospital and not the morgue”. It typically presupposes that a weapon could or will be used at any given point in a confrontation.

I realize that the video just shows a single second of a confrontational flow.

It’s amazing how rolling back can be effective. Have you ever dodged an insect buzzing toward your face? In tennis, there have been multiple times when the ball was coming at my head and a slight rolling back saved me. My playing partners would say “wow! Nice move”

 

[windwalker099]

How does the shang shou version of this differs from the FMA version of this. One FMA philosophy is, “better to go to the hospital and not the morgue”. It typically presupposes that a weapon could or will be used at any given point in a confrontation.

With out being very familiar, with FMA.
The underling theory on which its based on is different.
What is being controlled directly, seems to be different that what has been mentioned
indirectly in sports or in other MA...

Would be interested if you feel they are the same...

"Understanding the State of "Shang Shou"
By Tang Fengchi

When in the state of Shang Shou, there is no internal resistance between oneself and the
opponent. You do not engage in forceful struggle, and the opponent cannot exert their strength
effectively. "

"8. Real and Virtual Contact Points
Real points refer to physical contact where the internal energy connects with the opponent’s
energy. However, the two forces remain distinct, like “well water does not mix with river
water. ”

Virtual points, on the other hand, may or may not involve physical contact, but the
connection is established through intent and awareness, allowing the practitioner to control the
opponent’s center of energy (zhong)."


Different teacher's talk about it in different ways..

重心 Zhòngxīn center of gravity.

Master Wang Peisheng : The resultant force is zero

Ben Lo mentioned

"So I need to reverse my approach. I need to take my own power down to 0. Then there’s no chasing or spiraling. Nothing can change. If he has 100, I have 0. If he has 150, I have 0. If he has 200, I still have 0, on and on, whatever he has, I’m always beneath it, it doesn’t change or affect me. I’m not chasing his attributes, or competing, or catching up, or exceeding him. That’s Taijiquan.”

Interesting concept... hard to get....

"Shang Shou" represents a state of mastery where the practitioner is no longer bound by rigid forms or techniques.
Instead, they embody the principles of Taiji, allowing them to interact seamlessly with any situation, whether in combat, self-cultivation, or daily life.

​

​

 

[Holmejr]

With out being very familiar, with FMA.
The underling theory on which its based on is different.
What is being controlled directly, seems to be different that what has been mentioned
indirectly in sports or in other MA...

Would be interested if you feel they are the same...

"Understanding the State of "Shang Shou"
By Tang Fengchi

When in the state of Shang Shou, there is no internal resistance between oneself and the
opponent. You do not engage in forceful struggle, and the opponent cannot exert their strength
effectively. "

"8. Real and Virtual Contact Points
Real points refer to physical contact where the internal energy connects with the opponent’s
energy. However, the two forces remain distinct, like “well water does not mix with river
water. ”

Virtual points, on the other hand, may or may not involve physical contact, but the
connection is established through intent and awareness, allowing the practitioner to control the
opponent’s center of energy (zhong)."


Different teacher's talk about it in different ways..

重心 Zhòngxīn center of gravity.

Master Wang Peisheng : The resultant force is zero

Ben Lo mentioned

"So I need to reverse my approach. I need to take my own power down to 0. Then there’s no chasing or spiraling. Nothing can change. If he has 100, I have 0. If he has 150, I have 0. If he has 200, I still have 0, on and on, whatever he has, I’m always beneath it, it doesn’t change or affect me. I’m not chasing his attributes, or competing, or catching up, or exceeding him. That’s Taijiquan.”

Interesting concept... hard to get....

"Shang Shou" represents a state of mastery where the practitioner is no longer bound by rigid forms or techniques.
Instead, they embody the principles of Taiji, allowing them to interact seamlessly with any situation, whether in combat, self-cultivation, or daily life.

​

​

Being zero even if your opponent 200 is a lofty goal indeed. We do a thing called tapi tapi. It’s a give and take exercise similar to chi sao in WC except we incorporate weapons. Typically a rattan stick. During this particular exercise, we try to work in as many locks and disarms as possible. We often do this blind folded using as close to zero energy as possible. It’s actually very liberating when you get in that zone. In that zone you can periodically sense when your opponent is going to move just before he does move. Doesn’t happen often for me, but it does happen.