drop bear
Sr. Grandmaster
I am on a fighting thread. So you need to accept something or other.
Anyway your way or the highway with the reasoning that it is what you have always done is not accepting the wider view.
State of Mind when Fighting?
- Thread starter BeeBrian
- Start date
I am on a fighting thread. So you need to accept something or other.
Anyway your way or the highway with the reasoning that it is what you have always done is not accepting the wider view.
Chris Parker
Grandmaster
Again… frog in a well.
Shai Hulud
Purple Belt
It may be difficult for most people to keep "calm and collected" during situations of high intensity and tension, so I will just say that your state of mind must be such that you tap into your training as if it were second-nature. Needless to say that to arrive at this point, you will have to train. A lot.
The objectives that you will commit yourself to in every scuffle/engagement/fight however, will vary. In real-life self-defense situations on the street or wherever, where essentially you have a street-fight on your hands, you may have to prioritize control and escaping to remove yourself from danger. Someone serving in the force may have to prioritize disabling, maiming, or even killing targets should circumstances require (which may also work for general self-defense, but manslaughter and assault charges because you overdid it are unpleasant). Someone in competitive combat sports will have to mentally note the rules of his art. Is it to deliver a KO hit to the head? Land a number of strikes in good form? In this third case, you will have to focus on winning sport-specifically.
The objectives that you will commit yourself to in every scuffle/engagement/fight however, will vary. In real-life self-defense situations on the street or wherever, where essentially you have a street-fight on your hands, you may have to prioritize control and escaping to remove yourself from danger. Someone serving in the force may have to prioritize disabling, maiming, or even killing targets should circumstances require (which may also work for general self-defense, but manslaughter and assault charges because you overdid it are unpleasant). Someone in competitive combat sports will have to mentally note the rules of his art. Is it to deliver a KO hit to the head? Land a number of strikes in good form? In this third case, you will have to focus on winning sport-specifically.
drop bear
Sr. Grandmaster
He is Italian. The dude gets emotional.
Chris Parker
Grandmaster
When training/rolling? If so… find someone better.
ShotoNoob
Master Black Belt
|
The time to "fix it" is during karate training. It's the karate mental foundation that carries the day.
drop bear
Sr. Grandmaster
which becomes separate to mindset though. Here you are intellectualising aside from finding a suitable emotional state.
It is an element and relates to mindset though. One effects the other.
drop bear
Sr. Grandmaster
Kyle noke is the only guy better. And he doesn't come to Australia often enough.
Chris Parker
Grandmaster
I feel you and I have very different scales of what is "good" or "better"…
drop bear
Sr. Grandmaster
which is why karate dominates the striking styles. And Japan dominates karate?
Shai Hulud
Purple Belt
This is correct. I was merely stressing that state of mind in this case should not be an end in itself, but a means by which one may achieve his/her immediate objectives and goals in a fight.
drop bear
Sr. Grandmaster
I am going off fight matrix.
Fight Matrix Current MMA Rankings raquo Welterweight - Page OrgFilter NatFilter AU OrgFilter2 AgeFromFilter AgeToFilter TeamFilter StateFilter
What method are you using?
Chris Parker
Grandmaster
The distinction needs to be made between mind-set (internal state during an engagement) and tactical aims (escape, "win", survive, attack, etc). They are not the same thing.
Chris Parker
Grandmaster
A lot more than being able to win a competition or two. Frankly, to me, that's completely unimpressive.
ShotoNoob
Master Black Belt
|
So often karate is compared to the common MMA styles based largely on technical comparisons, the physicality. Your question highlights the mental equation which is so over-ridingly important, especially if you are facing a physically domineering opponent.
|
Traditional karate strives for the second supposition you presented, and another posted has commented on what I think is exactly the Japanese karate term (concept) that addresses your question. I like to study & refer to Shotokan karate because the Shotokan curriculum spells out these terms specifically, on mental training & the mental qualities to be developed by the karateka.
|
I'll comment on why the state of mind is important later, like to see / review how some of the other posters respond....
BTW: My reference for the Japanese karate mindset, see Chris Parker, Page 1, 12:45am.
drop bear
Sr. Grandmaster
This is correct. I was merely stressing that state of mind in this case should not be an end in itself, but a means by which one may achieve his/her immediate objectives and goals in a fight.
Yeah if we could be bothered there would be some sort of graph between the mindset and the task. Where one effects the other.
drop bear
Sr. Grandmaster
he is quite the hip hop dancer as well.
ShotoNoob
Master Black Belt
|
Here is the original post "problem statement."
|
Right, I had the same thought, although the tactical aims are relevant. IMO, The OP spoke directly to the "internal state," as you put it.
|
The comments made about the tactical aims, bring out two important point regarding the traditional martial arts. (1) The knowledge & understanding of what exactly the mental dimension in training is, is far less developed than the physical techniques & form. So we shouldn't be surprised when martial artists mix the "internals" with "aims." (2) The comments about the "aims" were important because the mental discipline sought in karate is a package of attributes, which function together & also in a number of ways. So bringing in a separate but inclusive attribute by the posters was very valuable.
|
BTW: I see Shai H. caught this thought as I was typing, that was damn fast....
Last edited:
Shai Hulud
Purple Belt
Thank you!
What you, Chris P. and others have pointed out, and what I have tried to point out I feel is very important. Mindset/disposition =/= tactics or goals. The former will have to be conditioned through training, resulting in mental clarity such that one will be able to draw on her trained drills, combinations and techniques for use in combat. The latter, however, will change depending on circumstances.
What Drop Bear has pointed out, that one will inevitably affect the other, is also true. While one's state of mind will determine her focus and fighting edge and spirit, this state of mind will only be achieved if one has sufficient training in the martial art's tactics and is prudent enough to discern between them in accordance with a situation as it arises. Like two legs that are absolutely essential for walking. One needs the other for support.
ShotoNoob
Master Black Belt
|
I train traditional style karate, so that is why I refer to karate, as my frame of reference. And because the karate style is so popular.
|
The concept you set forth is vastly overlooked among so many participating in martial arts, particularly MMA, IMO. I believe the failing of so many karateka, whether it be in karate competitions, or in MMA (or self defense), is founded in your reasoning. What I refer to as Mental Discipline, you more accurately explain as "mental clarity" combined with "tactical skill & expertise."
|
To put this into the perspective of actual application, I like to say that the physically superior fighter (the athlete) /can not prevail/ over the mentally-adept fighter who is physically well conditioned (karate).
Similar threads
