CoolKempoDude, No they wouldn't, different concepts. Clubs are classified as 'impact' weapons, knives as 'edged' weapons. In club defense you don't have to be 'so exacting'. Let me explain. A club is an extension of your reach. Defending against a club is similar to defending against a good Korean-style head kicker. You have to be close enought to 'kiss' him on the cheek to disarm him. Now, if you're not ready to move in (you don't want to hesitate going in or you may get caught half way) then you simply move the target, which is you!, either by ducking or stepping to another plane. This may be done as many times as it takes until you are ready to lunge in. If its a baseball bat with a baseball-type swing you can go in on the forward swing (when he cocks the bat back) or the reverse swing (cross-club), you may trap and uitilize close combat or infighting techniques to neutralize him. Depending on the length of the impact weapon, the attacker needs room to create momentum to develop power in the swing, in the case of a bat or tire iron, he needs more room than let's say a 'blackjack". A knife needs no room at a all, does not neccessarily need momentum or power, just a slight movement can be deadly. That's what I mean about being more exacting. You have to be conscience of where that knife is at all times. With the knife, control of the knife weilding arm is imperative and should you both go to the ground you can still be cut and/or killed. Say you rush in and jam a bat weilding opponent hard and you both go to the ground (that has happened in real encounters), you don't have to be concerned so much about the bat as you grapple with and neutralize the assailant. In close encounters I'm more comfortable dealing with a gun or club in close than a knife. Take a gun, you have two 'givens'. 1) the bullet comes out in linear motion and 2) you have to pull the trigger to fire it. No surprises! Very predictable but a knife can cut you from eight different angles and can be slashing, stabbing, poking, overhead, etc., unpredictable as to what the assailant will do. Also the other more comfortable part when dealing with a gun, you can grab the gun and hand while disarming, with the knife you can end up cutting a tendon or cutting your wrists. So even though there are some similiarities with the gun and knife techniques, there is still a difference and gun techniques are a 'modification' of knife, can be similiar but still different! Clubs defenses are most definitely different than the knife.