OP
- Thread Starter
- #21
Sorry for not getting back to this thread sooner. Been a bit busy, but I will say that there're some fantastic replies here!
Now, yes, my teachers, other teachers out there...they all are teaching things that are effective. Sure, some of it could be that a student just doesn't understand a particular tech., so that would be why they'd feel that its not effective. Other times the tech. is understood, but there may be something else that they'd feel more confortable executing...you know, those 'sure shot, bread and butter' techniques, that we tend to fall back on.
And yes, for the ones who've tested their techs. in real life...sure, unless we run out, start a fight and test that way, we have to rely on testing in the dojo, with as much realism as possible.
Just like we can benefit from many of the other arts out there, we benefit from the various techs. But, I still maintain that we need to find what works for US, seeing that WE would be the one using the technique, not our teacher. We are all built differently, so what may work well for them, due to size and strength differences, does not always mean we're going to have the same ease.
My point of the thread here, was not to discredit a technique. I mean, I teach techniques to people that I'm not fond of, yet I teach them because the person learning may find that tech. to be his bread and butter move. My point of the thread was to figure out why someone would automatically assume that everything is going to work with the same ease for everyone out there.
Now, yes, my teachers, other teachers out there...they all are teaching things that are effective. Sure, some of it could be that a student just doesn't understand a particular tech., so that would be why they'd feel that its not effective. Other times the tech. is understood, but there may be something else that they'd feel more confortable executing...you know, those 'sure shot, bread and butter' techniques, that we tend to fall back on.
And yes, for the ones who've tested their techs. in real life...sure, unless we run out, start a fight and test that way, we have to rely on testing in the dojo, with as much realism as possible.
Just like we can benefit from many of the other arts out there, we benefit from the various techs. But, I still maintain that we need to find what works for US, seeing that WE would be the one using the technique, not our teacher. We are all built differently, so what may work well for them, due to size and strength differences, does not always mean we're going to have the same ease.
My point of the thread here, was not to discredit a technique. I mean, I teach techniques to people that I'm not fond of, yet I teach them because the person learning may find that tech. to be his bread and butter move. My point of the thread was to figure out why someone would automatically assume that everything is going to work with the same ease for everyone out there.