Not black and white. Just because you use enough control not to KO people or punching them full force in the liver doesn't mean you are not fighting. Yes, I will be less experienced than someone doing full contact, but that does not make what I do glorified dancing.
No, it doesn't mean someone is just doing glorified dancing.....but without hard contact, someone isn't fully preparing for hard contact either.
There is more to fighting than punching and kicking.
An experienced judoka can kick ***, yet he doesn't spar acording to your definition. He uses throws and locks instead of kicks and punches.
I am a newbie at ninpo, but I have 3,5 years of ju-jitsu experience with locks, throws etc. So while I won't stand a chance in a standing distance fight, if I can come close enough to grab hold, I am definitely a match for someone who hasn't focused on that.
That's because Judoka (I am one) randori, and train EXACTLY how they fight......by slamming each other in to the mat, throwing on chokes and armbars full power, and generally sparring hard. By 'hard contact' I don't just mean Muay Thai or boxing.....I mean hard sparring. Grapplers spar hard, and engage in heavy physical contact. They learn what it's like to have their head in a vice, with someone torquing down, crushing the air out, and the panic of being pinned and unable to move.....and then learn to operate in that environment.
Have you ever seen the gracie challenge fights, where royce gracie challenged MA teachers to fight? most distance fighters didn't have a clue what to do when royce got in and worked his stuff.
Ah, but again the Gracies train like they fight........hard sparring, choking and throwing on arm bars at full power, tapping each other out, and even choking each other out. Hard contact, repeated over and over again until training is as much like fighting as can possibly be done.
so no full contact does not mean that you are unprepared to fight. It depends on how you train, how you spar and what your style is.
I disagree.......as I pointed out earlier, preparing for a physical altercation without physical contact, is like preparing to play tackle football by practicing touch football......you can only learn so much without being under the pressure of hitting and being hit, and learning what it's like to hit and be hit. Yes, it's better than doing nothing.......but it's certainly not a substitute for hard contact, if it is one's goal to realistically prepare for a physical struggle. If that's not one's goal, then so be it. We live in a society where it really isn't necessary to fight.....there are alternatives and options.
I am pretty sure that even in football practise, team mates don't hit each other with all of the nastiness that is used in the field. They will perform takedowns and tackles, but they are not intent on really hurting each other. And even if they do in the major league, they won't in the minor league. And that doesn't mean that the minor leaguers don't play football.
Nor is a sparing partner trying to hurt the other sparing partner by punching and kicking them.....but they ARE trying to recreate, as close as possible, real conditions WITHOUT inflicting injury. That is the point. The more realistic the practice, the more one prepares for the real thing.
In short, anything less than full contact is less than full preparation. If someone is satisified with partial preparation, that's fine with me.......we just need to be honest with ourselves about our own level of training and capability. Just because someone isn't training to peak, doesn't mean they can't handle MANY situations......but it's not to the same level of preparation as it could be.
If the full contact fighter is not also training in grapling / wrestling / submission, he is also not fully preparing.
If a full contact fighter has no experience with jiu-jitsu style fighting, then it all depends on who can dictate the distance.
Btw, youtube has a large collection of the gracie fights to prove this point. search for 'gracie vs kungfu' or 'gracie vs xxx'
There's the confusion........Randori IS full contact impact......we're not just talking about stand up striking. We're talking about slamming and being slammed to the mat, choking and being choked, etc. Randori is to Judo what full contact sparring is to boxing and muay thai.
I agree with the 5 finger floating palm remark.
In ninpo we also learn about the location of pressure points etc. But if your basic skills are not up to snuff, they that knowledge won't do you any good. On the other hand, if you spend years and years on the basics, then the more exotic stuff can give you an edge. You can't take shortcuts though.
True, but you learn how to fire that basic shot under pressure by having someone firing punches at your head. That's why boxers are the MASTERS of the basics.......most boxers learn 6 basic punches....8 if you count overhand right and overhand left. Many only use 4 different types of punches in a given fight. But they have mastered them through repetation, and HONED their skill under hard contact sparring. Boxers learn how to stay cool under pressure by training under pressure, and they learn to fire off their arsenal in situations where someone else is returning fire.