So we're you being eye gouged by the guy your on the ground with or soemone from behind or both?
I believe he's saying that the guy on the bottom was attempting the eye gouge, but due to the chaos of the situation, he originally thought it was one of the people who was trying to separate them (accidentally?) grabbing his eye sockets.
i can see how that sort of confusion could occur. Just another example of how things get a lot more complicated once you move past a simple one-on-one fight.