evenflow1121
2nd Black Belt
If you earned it you earned it.
Double Promotions
- Thread starter bignick
- Start date
beau_safken
Black Belt
Hmm well I dont know if I am good or bad for having skipped ranks twice while doing TKD... White to Orange skipping yellow, Orange to blue skipping green... I always thought I was kinda cheating the system, but I guess maybe I can take the egocentric way out and just admit I wasnt too bad. Regardless, It still feels weird...
I'm in a situation where I will possibly double-promote at the BB level, according to an organization. I tested for my WTF 1st dan in 1985. I switched schools & tested for 2nd dan in an ITF-style org in 1988. (No kids, those dates aren't typo's) I'm now back in the WTF where I accepted as a 2nd dan. When I test for 3rd, it will be a technical double promtion as far as the WTF is concerned. It will be odd in some respects, but not totally. Its been a long time in process.
still learning
Senior Master
Hello, As far as Joe Lewis getting his Black Belt? He earn it! The Sensi saw how Joe was beating all his Black Belts. There requirments was not about time...but about your skills....Joe has practice other forms of fighting too.
People who get double promotions is because of there hard work and skills in the art they are taking.
No one should believe you should be promoted because you train a long time? Promotions are about skills. There are many fast learners, and people who loves the training and gives it a 150% or more to there training.....Off course they may get promote faster!
"Congratutions on you double promotion"....Your Teacher know you deserved it.
This happens in alot of schools/systems. Even in your working jobs job...work extra hard...expect promotions...............Aloha
People who get double promotions is because of there hard work and skills in the art they are taking.
No one should believe you should be promoted because you train a long time? Promotions are about skills. There are many fast learners, and people who loves the training and gives it a 150% or more to there training.....Off course they may get promote faster!
"Congratutions on you double promotion"....Your Teacher know you deserved it.
This happens in alot of schools/systems. Even in your working jobs job...work extra hard...expect promotions...............Aloha
Shirt Ripper
Black Belt
bignick said:
..and don't you forget it!
:2xBird2:
OP
OP
IcemanSK said:Thanks, Nick. Elvis is the man! Chuck Norris has nothing on him
That's what you think...Elvis said that once too...I think we all know how that turned out...Elvis died of complications and such from "drug abuse" and when I say drugs, I mean a Chuck Norris roundhouse kick and when I say abuse, I mean to the face...
As the giver and recipient of double promotions in the past, I can say that I am not opposed to such practices, provided that:
1) The student has honestly demonstrated a remarkable, consistent ability throughout the time period between the previous test and the current one. This is a much better measure of worthiness, in my opinion.
2) The student has demonstrated a good, consistent work ethic throughout that same time period.
3) The instructor evaluates things in an unbiased manner.
There are other times where I'd say "go ahead":
Sometimes a student has learned everything needed for that next rank a good bit early, and is taught the following rank's requirements as well. If he can do both with high proficiency in addition to the above, then I see no reason to hold him back. I would actually have him test twice in the same day.
Sometimes a student comes in with a lot of previous experience, and started at a much lower rank. These types of students can, and often times do, pick up everything they need to know for their next rank well before the next testing period.
In a nutshell, double promotions (or possibly even more) aren't necessarily out of the ordinary. Keep in mind, that there are many styles of Karate that would use only white, green, brown, and black belts, and that the extra colored belts were thrown in there to help people advance in a more conservative manner. Still, there were many folks who did just fine with that system.
1) The student has honestly demonstrated a remarkable, consistent ability throughout the time period between the previous test and the current one. This is a much better measure of worthiness, in my opinion.
2) The student has demonstrated a good, consistent work ethic throughout that same time period.
3) The instructor evaluates things in an unbiased manner.
There are other times where I'd say "go ahead":
Sometimes a student has learned everything needed for that next rank a good bit early, and is taught the following rank's requirements as well. If he can do both with high proficiency in addition to the above, then I see no reason to hold him back. I would actually have him test twice in the same day.
Sometimes a student comes in with a lot of previous experience, and started at a much lower rank. These types of students can, and often times do, pick up everything they need to know for their next rank well before the next testing period.
In a nutshell, double promotions (or possibly even more) aren't necessarily out of the ordinary. Keep in mind, that there are many styles of Karate that would use only white, green, brown, and black belts, and that the extra colored belts were thrown in there to help people advance in a more conservative manner. Still, there were many folks who did just fine with that system.
artyon:
Grenadier said:
Exactly. I don't have a set schedule for testing and if a student sticks around long enough they likely will go straight to 5th Kyu. If I was teaching kids then the lower kyus are needed but in general theres no emphasis on testing or getting ready for a test. they need to be always ready and I'll know that.
I generally use 5th kyu and 3rd kyu (because of the lenth of time between gradings and they also don't know when I'm going to promote them either). From there they may go to 2nd kyu but I've had a few go from 3rd kyu to 1st kyu. (In the same breath) I promoted a 3rd kyu to Shodan after being a 3rd kyu for 3 years.
So it really matters on the school and how it is run and the attendace of the student and how they progress.
SAVAGE
Blue Belt
bignick said:
Congrats...I myself got a three rank jump from Goju Ryu Karate...it did make me feel unconfortable...but I am the only person to have ever jumped!
My dojo isnt a belt factory either...I took it up with sensei and he just smiled...I took it as a vote of confidence that he had in my ability and it only made me work harder to live up to senseis expectations!
BTW I worked my *** off before that grading so that I would be prepared..I learnt more Kata than I had to..I sparred with 220% and just went balls to the walls! Like I am sure you did as well!
Miles
Senior Master
My first instructor rarely gave double promotions but both of my brothers received one. I never got one but 30 years later I outrank them!
In the last 10 yrs of teaching, I have double-promoted 1 student who had not tested during the normal testing cycle but continued to practice diligently.
Miles
In the last 10 yrs of teaching, I have double-promoted 1 student who had not tested during the normal testing cycle but continued to practice diligently.
Miles
bushidomartialarts
Senior Master
if your instructor double promoted you and you trust your instructor's skill and intent, than accept the promotion.
congratulations, by the way! your instructor must think a lot of you and have great respect for your dedication and skill.
congratulations, by the way! your instructor must think a lot of you and have great respect for your dedication and skill.
I experienced a similar thing. I was promoted from 5th kyu, a white belt in the style I study, to 1st kyu. Now before any naysayers start in, that was after four years of four classes a week. My instuctor never just got around to testing anybody for a long while. There were a few other white belts there, and none tested as high as i did, but they weren't there nearly as long as I was. Now, after about three more years, i'm testing for my shodan in a couple of months. I hope, but know it won't be, easier than my brown testing.
I remember a school whose instructor's daughter was a second dgree brown belt on a monday, and was a 3rd Black by Friday! Apparently this rank would look better for teaching at the school. A lot of McDojos have done this, so, unfortunately, it's not uncommon.
Similar threads
