Bong Sau & Shoulder problems

lucky i wasnt taught with the bong sao to bong higher than my shoulder

Well to be precise, the elbow shouldn't be torqued up higher than the shoulder, ...but of course the bong sau itself, i.e. the arm, can be angled upward higher than the shoulder if necessary.

For example: Imagine somebody who's about 5'2" doing poon sau with someone over 6'2". Their arms will have to angle upward.
 
Sounds like you are thinking of your "Rhino Guard" position again?
When you use your right hand to grab on your opponent's lapel, your opponent's left hand can still punch you. If you just raise your right elbow and hide your head next to it, it's the best defense for that position. The Bong Shou is an excellent tool to be used in stand up grappling to avoid a head punch.

In the following picture, if the person on the right throws a left hook punch toward the head of the person on the left, the person on the left can raise his right elbow, hide his head next to it, and avoid that hook punch.

lapel_hold.gif
 
When you use your right hand to grab on your opponent's lapel, your opponent's left hand can still punch you. If you just raise your right elbow and hide your head next to it, it's the best defense for that position. The Bong Shou is an excellent tool to be used in stand up grappling to avoid a head punch.

In the following picture, if the person on the right throws a left hook punch toward the head of the person on the left, the person on the left can raise his right elbow, hide his head next to it, and avoid that hook punch.

lapel_hold.gif
That would not be bong sao. At least not as I learned.
 
That would not be bong sao. At least not as I learned.
It may not be what Bong Shou was designed for, but it can be what Bong Shou can be evolved into. IMO, we should look into the future and not just look at the past. The future should always be better than the past otherwise our human being will be in trouble.
 
It may not be what Bong Shou was designed for, but it can be what Bong Shou can be evolved into. IMO, we should look into the future and not just look at the past. The future should always be better than the past otherwise our human being will be in trouble.

But there is no need to "evolve" the Bong Sau. The Bong Sau simply transitions into another technique....the Feng Sau or Biu Sau. If the elbow bends past 45 degrees, I would argue that it is now a Lan Sau.
 
But there is no need to "evolve" the Bong Sau. The Bong Sau simply transitions into another technique....the Feng Sau or Biu Sau. If the elbow bends past 45 degrees, I would argue that it is now a Lan Sau.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dping a good bong sao takes good corrections and understanding the path of the bong sao.
Fortunately I have had no shoulder problems from wing chun. But hopping tall weeds using bad motions once caused me problems
 
------------------------------------------------------------------------
hopping tall weeds using bad motions once caused me problems

upload_2016-1-10_10-18-55.webp


Yes young Grasshopper. Though you are able to perform the task, one must be careful to not harm one's body in the process.
 
Grasshopper...weedhopper... I believe Joy was chopping tall weeds. I find it very hard to imagine him hopping tall weeds! :D
 
I agree with Danny. In CSL that would be more of a "Feng Sau." Other's I think might call it a "Biu Sau."
KPM, could you link an image or video to see the Feng Sau technique? I'd like to know how to apply it.Thank you!
 

Latest Discussions

Back
Top