In the RAF that's known as 'pull up a sandbag..'
Attacked and Outnumbered
- Thread starter Jujutsuka
- Start date
In the RAF that's known as 'pull up a sandbag..'
Kickboxer101
Master Black Belt
It's not like he was saying he used a 360 tornado kick to knock a guy out then ran off the wall with a show time kick. Fact is yeah it could be bs but fact is I think a fair few people here will have used their training one way or another and there's no reason to call them liars for no reason simply because they posted an experience. I mean if he said he about 20 guys without taking a hit then yeah obviously that's rubbish but there's nothing from this story that says he's a liar. More he just kept them away until security turned up
Who called them 'liars'?
Steve
Mostly Harmless
I think there is a difference between calling someone a liar and expressing healthy skepticism.
You're right that we shouldn't be calling each other liars. Its rude. But that doesn't mean we have to accept everything that is written at face value. There is a lot of BS posted around here.
You're right that we shouldn't be calling each other liars. Its rude. But that doesn't mean we have to accept everything that is written at face value. There is a lot of BS posted around here.
Kickboxer101
Master Black Belt
Well plenty of people posting "hmm" showing they doubt the story and others saying how it's difficult to remember these things showing they don't believe it either.
I had the same on mine with my thread about a guy starting trouble with me and pulling a knife I got people posting hmm and that wasnt even an exciting story I threw one punch (a pretty crappy punch and ran off) and yet people doubted that as well that's what my point is
Hmmm.
And what does that mean? It could be quite a few things actually, I think you are putting a meaning on it that's not there. They aren't saying it's lies, they are saying, in a far less wordy way, that the story be true but most likely not, it could be embellished or misremembered. It's expressing doubt but not calling it lies.
You have to bear in mind that many of us have been on this site for years and in that time we've seen a lot of stuff posted up and being keen observers of human nature and having a lot of life experience and being older than many posters we actually know that certain things when posted are unlikely to be true. In short we all have well developed BS detectors.
Kickboxer101
Master Black Belt
Well why doesn't he simply state his point that's my issue why give just a vague thing like that which like you said could mean anything just say what you think.
My bet is its a flashbulb memory. He remembers it very clearly, almost unbelievably so, but that doesn't necessarily mean he's lying about it. It also doesn't mean it's 100% correct. People have flashbulb memories that they are fully convinced are exactly how something happened, only to find out from other sources that they're not entirely accurate.
He did say what he meant, he said hmm. I didn't say it could mean anything. I told you exactly what it meant, he just said it more succinctly.
D
Deleted member 34973
Guest
One thing about Martial talk, there is a lot of questionable experience and experiences, when it comes to fighting.
pgsmith
Master of Arts
Hmmmmm ....
Steve
Mostly Harmless
Liar.
I'd read it as saying "I'm skeptical of this, but whatever... it's not worth arguing about."
Similarly, someone may click the "disagree" button without commenting. Pretty much the same thing. "I disagree with what you're saying, but am not interested in arguing about it."
oftheherd1
Senior Master
You too? Didn't think I would catch you did you?
Actually, I agree completely with your comments on memory. Funny thing memory.
There is no rules in the street fighting, don't confront them be safe quick finish and left the place asap
