Kwan Jang
Purple Belt
I hope such a ratio NEVER apllies to me because it would indicate that I am a horrible teacher. If you brought your child to an elite prep school to prepare your child for higher education (ex. Ivy League Universities) and the headmaster bragged "we only graduate on e student out of 100" (let alone 2000), would you see that as a positive or a negative? I would see it as an indication that they needed to learn more about teaching and meeting the needs of the students.
I STRONGLY believe in VERY high standards for advanced students, especially black belts. As an industry, the quality of "our product" is the quality of our advanced students. However, I believe that the instructor(s) bare much of the burden of lifting the students up to that level. Of course, you can't do it for them, but how well you motivate, structure the classes and curriculum and guide them through the journey makes a huge difference. IMO, far too many instructors stand as a barrier between students and their success and have the attitude that "you have to get through me to achieve this".
I am NOT in favor of watering down the standards for black belt, just the opposite, I feel that far too many are too lax towards it. However, I believe the instructors and master instructors bare the greater burden in this process and that they often pass the blame on to the student when that failure occurs. I do realize that the student (or if a child, student and parent) must do their part, but they came to us to learn certain life skills and obtain certain qualities and we need to do our very best to deliver.
I STRONGLY believe in VERY high standards for advanced students, especially black belts. As an industry, the quality of "our product" is the quality of our advanced students. However, I believe that the instructor(s) bare much of the burden of lifting the students up to that level. Of course, you can't do it for them, but how well you motivate, structure the classes and curriculum and guide them through the journey makes a huge difference. IMO, far too many instructors stand as a barrier between students and their success and have the attitude that "you have to get through me to achieve this".
I am NOT in favor of watering down the standards for black belt, just the opposite, I feel that far too many are too lax towards it. However, I believe the instructors and master instructors bare the greater burden in this process and that they often pass the blame on to the student when that failure occurs. I do realize that the student (or if a child, student and parent) must do their part, but they came to us to learn certain life skills and obtain certain qualities and we need to do our very best to deliver.