Why correct grammar is so important
- Thread starter Balrog
- Start date
Last night on TV, I had heard the US ex-president said, "... no nothing ...".
Why did he say that?
Why did he say that?
Steve
Mostly Harmless
I didn't hear it, but I have heard people say "know nothing." As in, "Bob is a know nothing fool."
isshinryuronin
Senior Master
- Joined
- Feb 28, 2019
- Messages
- 2,481
- Reaction score
- 2,690
When an educated man says, "no nothing," on a TV address, it is likely he is doing so on purpose to ingratiate himself to the general public he is trying to appeal to. Past presidents have dyed their hair when addressing a college audience and let the gray show when addressing senior citizens. Other makeup and mannerisms are similarly tailored for the particular target.
Many politicians are chameleons, striving to adopt the appearance and communication style of their intended audience to facilitate the audience identifying with them. Top salespeople use similar tactics.
People generally like communicating with others like them - "He's just like me!" This often results in greater trust and tendency of agreement. Human nature. These tactics are not good or bad in themselves. Just like guns, or fists, it depends on how they're utilized.
Big power and money (which politics and business definitely are) is a high stakes game. It would be naive to think the players would not use every (legal?) advantage at their disposal to win over supporters. Their exact choice of words is not accidental. Speechwriters are paid very well for their skill in strategic composition, aimed at influencing (I'd say manipulate, but that may be too "martial" for some) public opinion.
This post is not really about politics, but about applied martial arts. One difference, though - combat is more honest. At least you know what the opponent's true intentions are.
Many politicians are chameleons, striving to adopt the appearance and communication style of their intended audience to facilitate the audience identifying with them. Top salespeople use similar tactics.
People generally like communicating with others like them - "He's just like me!" This often results in greater trust and tendency of agreement. Human nature. These tactics are not good or bad in themselves. Just like guns, or fists, it depends on how they're utilized.
Big power and money (which politics and business definitely are) is a high stakes game. It would be naive to think the players would not use every (legal?) advantage at their disposal to win over supporters. Their exact choice of words is not accidental. Speechwriters are paid very well for their skill in strategic composition, aimed at influencing (I'd say manipulate, but that may be too "martial" for some) public opinion.
This post is not really about politics, but about applied martial arts. One difference, though - combat is more honest. At least you know what the opponent's true intentions are.
I remember the sentence was, " ... no weapon, no nothing ...".
Do you think that the majority of US population like to use double negative?
Last edited:
Steve
Mostly Harmless
isshinryuronin
Senior Master
- Joined
- Feb 28, 2019
- Messages
- 2,481
- Reaction score
- 2,690
No. I should have included the word "general public segment" to illustrate a more specific target group.
When someone said, "You are bad man (or you are bad, man, not sure which one)", what does he mean?
I have learned 2 different ways to say "En, En". Have not heard anybody use it for a long time. Do anybody know why?
I have learned 2 different ways to say "En, En". Have not heard anybody use it for a long time. Do anybody know why?
The "no nothing" idiom is pretty widely used.
I don't think it approaches the definition of the appeal to common folk fallacy, though.
I don't even konw what that refers to.
Steve
Mostly Harmless
Depends on whether it is affected or not, doesn't it?
In politics, it's definitely a thing. For example, John Kennedy from Louisiana graduated magna cum laude from Vanderbilt University and graduated with honors from Oxford. You wouldn't know it by listening to him speak, which is very intentional.
Now, to be fair, some politicians aren't faking it... in which case it would not be a fallacy.
Last edited:
Steve
Mostly Harmless
Possibly in the South. I don't think it's super common around here.
I think for it to be that specific logical fallacy, it has to include that claim (even implicitly) that all common folk ______. Otherwise, it's just an attempt to be more relatable. It could be argued that there's an implicit claim that "I understand you because I'm just folks", but I'm not sure that meets the definition (as I understand it) for that logical fallacy.
I've heard it all over the country, though it is definitely more common in the South, where it's also lacking the ending "g".
Steve
Mostly Harmless
I live in the part of King County where pick up trucks are lifted and have testicles hanging from the trailer hitch. If there's anywhere in the area where they would say "no nothin'" it would be here. I believe you if you say you've heard it in Washington State. We say some weird stuff around here, but I can't recall ever hearing anyone around here say that. I'll listen for it now.
I have heard people being called "know nothings", though. As in, "So-and-so at the store was a know-nothing jackwagon."
It's entirely possible I've never heard it in Washington the Greater (the appropriate honorific for the state, IMO). And it probably is largely a cultural bleed from the South over the last 20-30 years. I only meant my comment to clarify that I've heard it in many areas of the US. Probably the Midwest is second to the South in usage, if I go entirely based on my very crappy memory.
Steve
Mostly Harmless
We all support the oxford comma. But what about the Walken Comma:
It can be either en-en, or un-un. I believe it means "no".
