In both a home, outside and non-commercial setting
I have always trained at home to supplement my training in a school.
Home is great except for the phone and the occasional interruptions
Outside is also a very good place to train except in the winter. However I cannot train any staff or Sword forms outside it draws too much attention from the neighbors.
Non-commercial settings I have trained in were actually quite Spartan but quite nice. Mostly a large room with a nice hard floor, lots of room to do what needed to be done. .
I train Shotokan karate in a somewhat commercial, somewhat non-commercial dojo. We have to pay monthly dues, but the instructors receive none of it and the money only goes to the rental of the building. I also practice at home, if that counts.
Partially because Grandmaster Shin started teaching in Seoul Central YMCA it's a tradition among my instructor and his family, who housed Grandmaster Shin when he came to America, to teach in YMCAs. The Ys really appreciate the classes and take good care of us. I went to Master White's school for a gup clinic and just before the clinic the Phillipsburg YMCA actually polished the floor for us. They almost never polish the floor. Mr. White, my instructor, has never had a problem with our YMCA and they allow him to hold three classes a week and use their meeting room if he needs to have a Black Belt meeting.
I started with Fred Villari's Studios. Then went to United Studios. Now, I train in a garage and a basement of a fitness gym (traditional kung fu classes are held there).
I originally started at the school of chinese martial arts in the metro detroit area. Currently living in another state, I practice by myself or with a couple of friends locally. I still try to return several times a year though, to practice with my sifu and get caught up on anything new happening.
I trained at the same commercial school for 35 years and have only had the one instructor. My own school is done from both my own home dojo and a rented hall.
I generally did work around the dojo or computer work for my sensei so paid for my instruction that way.
Currently, I train at home. But when I was training formally, I trained at both commercial and non-commercial studios. Both indoors and outdoors and in both "accredited" schools and clubs as well.
As someone stated before me, all my training experiences seemed appropriate for the environments in which I trained. None seemed odd to me. However, a bunch of guys whacking each other with shinai in the park, may have seemed odd to the uninitiated.
I started in a commercial Dojo did this for 5 years.
My teacher was a good person, My mom was the only parent around and the Dojo I went to really was kind to her issue. I had to help out with cleaning and what not. But it saved my mom $$$ when I was younger started at 12 years or age. Later I went to a Non- commercial dojo and
Now I train In a self owned Dojo that is growing faster than I think my teacher wants, But he has good help and he covers all classes.
My self I moved my Dojo to my home Changed the basement into a nice looking Dojo. about 5,000.00 to do this. you see nothing of a basement.
and its a back walk out. I also have a large place to hold classes out side
for that other training that i think a commercial dojo lacks.
I think thats what this was about. just had surgery on my should so maybe the meds are makeing me drift.
my 2 cents,
best to yall
steve
First place was in a church's basement. This was a really informal class, taught by a friend, though, and nobody was ever graded for rank.
Next place was at the fellowship hall of the local YWCA. My teacher was actually quite good (thanks, Sensei Sherrie!) and the rent was cheap, as were costs of the classes themselves. All I had to do was pay 25 bucks a month for tuition, and a yearly 20 dollar membership to the Y. I guess the only disadvantages were that the fellowship hall area had a dirty floor, and that the last Thursday of each month, the Y management would kick us out, so that the elderly folks could play Bingo. Once in a while, they'd let us use the main gynmasium, though.
When I went to college, we were using the fencing gym for classes. Big, wide, open area, and the semi-padded floor (floor had a bit of give, but still a relatively hard surface) had a good texture. The front of the gym had some polished steel mirrors, and we never had to worry about class schedules interfering with other groups. Dues were 50 bucks / semester, which was a phenomenally cheap price for some truly excellent training.
When I went to graduate school, I signed up with my first commercial, stand-alone school. Prices were much higher, at 50 bucks / month, but after seeing how the classes were conducted, and the quality of instruction, I was quite willing to pay the price.
Ever since then, I've been training at commercial, stand-alone schools. All of them have been well-equipped, and have high quality instruction. Furthermore, they are all places where there was always a very healthy mutual respect between my teachers and me. This combination isn't easy to find, and I'll consider myself fortunate to have found such places.
Two of these three schools had padded mats covering the floor, either the jigsaw types, or rectangular ones that stayed in place.
My current place has jigsaw mats available, but we prefer training on hardwood. I enjoy training on both types of surfaces, so it really makes no difference to me, now that my feet don't get blistered anymore!
Prices for tuition have varied from 55 bucks / month, all the way to 75 bucks / month at the recent schools, but it was certainly worth every penny spent.
My next door neighbor growing up was Master teacher Jon Collins. In 1979-80 Dr. Gyi lived at his house for several months. I began training in 1980 at a summer camp he offered. From that point on, I trained at his house or in the gymnasium at the college where he worked. Fast Forward to 1990. I began training other students for him at the gym and I taught self defense classes for the college - I mention this because I learned much from teaching. Then I branched out to experience other MA's but sought the same situations - I would meet someone with obvious skill and rank and offer to cross train with them, or I would attend a seminar. I picked up a great amount of Jiu Jitsu and TKD that way as well as a few wonderful Seminars from Sifu Innosanto.
EDIT: I also had to train quite extensively outside in natural settings. You wouldn't believe how fast you learn to "adapt" a long staff form with trees all around you! lol