What Kind Of Martial Arts Do You Do?

REMINDER TO MEMBERS:

Art/style bashing is not allowed, per the guidelines you agreed to when you signed up.

Gerry Seymour
MT Moderator
@gpseymour
 
Bill Mattocks said:
3rd Dan, Isshinryu. Master Mitchum lineage.
Click to expand...
Whenever I see reference to "lineage," I get a little amused. Up until a few years ago when I got "back" into karate, I never heard that term re: isshinryu. Introducing myself to a younger practitioner, he asked me my lineage. I was very confused. I searched my mind for an answer, and found only one - "Shimabuku lineage."

When I got my black belt, there was only one 10th dan "Soke." Tatsuo was still around. I believe my shodan certificate carried his mark. I don't believe there was anyone who claimed to be a 9th or even 8th degree at that time. To this day, while I follow my sensei in following Uechi, who followed Uezo, I still consider that we all share and follow the Shimabuku lineage and those he learned from.
 
isshinryuronin said:
Whenever I see reference to "lineage," I get a little amused. Up until a few years ago when I got "back" into karate, I never heard that term re: isshinryu. Introducing myself to a younger practitioner, he asked me my lineage. I was very confused. I searched my mind for an answer, and found only one - "Shimabuku lineage."

When I got my black belt, there was only one 10th dan "Soke." Tatsuo was still around. I believe my shodan certificate carried his mark. I don't believe there was anyone who claimed to be a 9th or even 8th degree at that time. To this day, while I follow my sensei in following Uechi, who followed Uezo, I still consider that we all share and follow the Shimabuku lineage and those he learned from.
Click to expand...
I mention it because there are differences in some kata, as well as bunkai breakdowns by omote and oyo.

I started training at age 46, I'm in my 61st year now. Although I knew Angi Uezu, he was not my sensei. I will never live long enough to reach high dan rank.

I admit to some pride in knowing my sensei trained directly under Sherman Harrill and Harold Mitchum. We strive to keep our kata as close as possible to what has been passed to us. While I never met Sensei Harrill, I have at least met and done kata with the late Sensei Mitchum at his home.

I hope my mention of lineage isn't off-putting, I don't mean to be divisive. We currently have several adult yudansha in our dojo who came from other isshinryu schools. They're of course our brothers and our family. Some of their movements seem odd to some of us, is all.
 
Bill Mattocks said:
I mention it because there are differences in some kata, as well as bunkai breakdowns by omote and oyo.

I started training at age 46, I'm in my 61st year now. Although I knew Angi Uezu, he was not my sensei. I will never live long enough to reach high dan rank.

I admit to some pride in knowing my sensei trained directly under Sherman Harrill and Harold Mitchum. We strive to keep our kata as close as possible to what has been passed to us. While I never met Sensei Harrill, I have at least met and done kata with the late Sensei Mitchum at his home.

I hope my mention of lineage isn't off-putting, I don't mean to be divisive. We currently have several adult yudansha in our dojo who came from other isshinryu schools. They're of course our brothers and our family. Some of their movements seem odd to some of us, is all.
Click to expand...
No problem claiming Mitchum lineage. He was one of the original Marine bangers of Tatsuo. The original difference in lineages, should be noted, is derived from the time period they studied with Shimabuku as he continued to make small changes, rather than differences in theory or the concept of isshinryu.

Sensei Harrill was a true student of karate and one of the first to rediscover the oyo bunkai. He was tough as well. Too bad he passed before his time. As for the high ranking American isshinryu guys now, I know of only the few true experts. The majority of other guys with red on their belts, well, uh, ...
 
Bill Mattocks said:
3rd Dan, Isshinryu. Master Mitchum lineage.
Click to expand...
Bill,

I remember your posts from color belts to today.
I have always appreciated your comments and insight and thoughts.

Everyone,
I teach two different styles of FMA (Filipino Martial Arts).
I started in Modern Arnis in 86.
I started in Balintawak in 94.

For Balintawak, our instructor (GM) Manong Ted Buot (Deceased) would say when one could teach.
This was for just a friend to a group to a seminar to you are able to just teach.
He also asked me and one other to carry on the system for him as he learned it from the Founder GM Bacon.

I don't use special titles (my choice) Marketing I use Master.
I wish everyone good and healthy training.
 
Eskrido de Alcuizar (FMA) for the last 5 years. Have a history of Thai Boxing / JKD.

Inosanto Eskrima/JKD (Torrance).
Ted Lucay Lucay Escrima.
Raf Viloria Derobio Escrima.
Steve Tarani/Jerry Hofmann FMA/Thai Boxing.
Ron Manrique - Eskrido de Alcuizar.
 
well my main style is the Glasgow Kiss. A Jockanese fighting system developed on the streets of Scotland.
 
4th Dan in Hapkido under GM Rodemaker
1st Dan Tae Kwon Do under M Tim Holmes

Haven't trained TDK in many years so not sure how valid it is for me anymore.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Hello from SE VA, USA

Previous Thread

Hello from Toronto

Next Thread

Latest Discussions

Back
Top