TKD is not flying-jumping and spining kicks
- Thread starter Manny
- Start date
JadeDragon3
Black Belt
I just calls em' like I sees em'.
That particular TKD school that I posted teaches Krav Maga as well as TKD. Master Eric Moberly has three other schools that teach TKD only. And no you are wrong, ANY martial art is good is just not true. Do you think that capoera(sp?) is good? It's very impractical, almost all the kicks are done from a handstand position. It might be good as far as exercise but for martial combat its very bad.
TKD as taught in the USA may has changed over the last 40 years. Back in the 1960's sparring in many TKD schools involved heavy contact. If you look at the history of professional "karate" in this country you will see many of the early champions where from TKD.
Sport, Olympic or non Olympic, and being child and family friendly has cause much change over the years but what is taught can be very devastating when taught not as a sport but as a means of survival.
Sport, Olympic or non Olympic, and being child and family friendly has cause much change over the years but what is taught can be very devastating when taught not as a sport but as a means of survival.
Sylo
Purple Belt
I enjoy the high flying kicks, and while not effective for SD. Being able to do them, means that my body is in excellent shape. I would never use them in a fight, but being able to perform them could mean that I am in much better condition to win the fight than someone else that can't. Takes alot of conditioning and leg strength to pull off some of those kicks. Imagine how much power my front and side kick would have.
wow you're stupid, THATS NOT A MARTIAL ART.
Twin Fist
Grandmaster
You have never seen any TKD from the texas Allen Steen lineage, clearly.
and by the way Hoss, you should be carefull, statements like:
"ANY martial art is good is just not true." show how much you dont know, rather than how much you DO know.
the art doesnt make the fight, the fighter makes the art.
Sylo
Purple Belt
I really don't think this should have turned into a donnybrook "my art is better... " argument. All martial arts, are made up of some form of kicking/punching. Some of them have added in grappling, and joint/pressure point strikes etc. However, the basis for all of them are very similar. So to say one is completely useless would be false, simply because they are all based on the same principle.
One may not be "as" effective as another, depending on many different variables that one person could never be able to name. What I would like to add is...
TKD does have powerful kicking and punching techniques. TKD does have leg conditioning and strengthening stances.
SD is about being in the best possible surroundings when the situation arises. you can even the odds, by learning a martial art or arts, and by keeping an open mind, and being aware of your surroundings. Many self defense fights are won simply by knowing the surroundings better than your opponent.
TKD helps me to keep a clear mind. There is alot of positive things to learn from it, as with any martial art. I feel confident in my ability to defend myself if the need ever arose. The cool thing is, I don't usually go around looking for fights so TKD works really well for me.
One may not be "as" effective as another, depending on many different variables that one person could never be able to name. What I would like to add is...
TKD does have powerful kicking and punching techniques. TKD does have leg conditioning and strengthening stances.
SD is about being in the best possible surroundings when the situation arises. you can even the odds, by learning a martial art or arts, and by keeping an open mind, and being aware of your surroundings. Many self defense fights are won simply by knowing the surroundings better than your opponent.
TKD helps me to keep a clear mind. There is alot of positive things to learn from it, as with any martial art. I feel confident in my ability to defend myself if the need ever arose. The cool thing is, I don't usually go around looking for fights so TKD works really well for me.
Empty Hands
Senior Master
I think the truth is in the middle. The ability of the fighter makes the most important difference, but some arts are more effective than others if the ability of the fighter in each is the same. Other arts are highly effective, but only in very specific circumstances - i.e. the sword arts or to a lesser extent BJJ.
ATTENTION ALL USERS:
Please, keep the conversation polite and respectful.
Brian R. VanCise
MartialTalk Super Moderator
Please, keep the conversation polite and respectful.
Brian R. VanCise
MartialTalk Super Moderator
Tkd is as useful as any other Martial Art if it is tought right. Better known as Texas Karate is one of the toughest styles around if you can find the right instructor. Come on look at all the water down programs and see for yourself. TKD gets the bad rap like Karate did before and in a few years some other art will be the new whipping child.
