zDom
Senior Master
- Joined
- Aug 21, 2006
- Messages
- 3,081
- Reaction score
- 111
I don't want to offend you, I'm just going to make a statement.
If you find it applies to you, fine. If not, also fine.
My dad taught me a basic karate punch when I was 10 years old. About that same time, I spent what I thought was a lot of time reading Bruce Tegner's self defense book.
From age 10-22 I met and "learned a few things" from and "trained" with several people over the years.
I used to think I knew a LOT about martial arts — until I started training 4 to 5 days per week, EVERY week, with a real martial art instructor, in a real martial art class.
Now, after about 20 years of training, week in and week out, I'm still not ready to "invent" my own martial art program — not for the handicapped, not for ANYBODY.
I've heard a lot of people ask, but I haven't seen you answer yet — what is your background? Have you been training — day in, day out — for all these years?
Yes, handicapped people face challenges when it comes to martial arts. And finding techniques that work for THEM is a HUGE challenge. Such a huge challenge, that it would take someone with a LOT of experience to come up with what is REALLY a feasible system for them.
If you are not as qualified as you think you are (and I'm not saying you are or are not qualified — still waiting to hear more about your experience before I form my opinion),
then you many actually be doing more harm than good by teaching people something they will believe in but will fail them when they think they can depend on it.
I'm sorry you are running into so much skepticism here — but most of us have put in long, hard hours training and, over the many, many years that we have been studying and training in martial arts, have met and conversed with plenty of people who think, after "learning a couple of moves from their uncle who was in the special forces" they can re-invent wheels we have been using for years and years and years and years and years.
If you find it applies to you, fine. If not, also fine.
My dad taught me a basic karate punch when I was 10 years old. About that same time, I spent what I thought was a lot of time reading Bruce Tegner's self defense book.
From age 10-22 I met and "learned a few things" from and "trained" with several people over the years.
I used to think I knew a LOT about martial arts — until I started training 4 to 5 days per week, EVERY week, with a real martial art instructor, in a real martial art class.
Now, after about 20 years of training, week in and week out, I'm still not ready to "invent" my own martial art program — not for the handicapped, not for ANYBODY.
I've heard a lot of people ask, but I haven't seen you answer yet — what is your background? Have you been training — day in, day out — for all these years?
Yes, handicapped people face challenges when it comes to martial arts. And finding techniques that work for THEM is a HUGE challenge. Such a huge challenge, that it would take someone with a LOT of experience to come up with what is REALLY a feasible system for them.
If you are not as qualified as you think you are (and I'm not saying you are or are not qualified — still waiting to hear more about your experience before I form my opinion),
then you many actually be doing more harm than good by teaching people something they will believe in but will fail them when they think they can depend on it.
I'm sorry you are running into so much skepticism here — but most of us have put in long, hard hours training and, over the many, many years that we have been studying and training in martial arts, have met and conversed with plenty of people who think, after "learning a couple of moves from their uncle who was in the special forces" they can re-invent wheels we have been using for years and years and years and years and years.