Flying Crane
Sr. Grandmaster
Hilarious!Yep, stance training, forms, two person drills, tui shou, etc. can all be useful tools and none of them individually are sufficient or necessary to learn how to fight. I'm not even convinced that sparring (as many define it anyway) is necessary or sufficient, just another very useful tool and one that's harder to replace than many others.
On another note, looking at your signature it appears we have the same first name as well!
anyways, I am not convinced that sparring is the pinnacle of training. It can be useful. Other things can also be useful. There are many kinds of sparring and some can be downright useless. So it really depends. But I do not believe it is absolutely essential. Other things can develop solid, useful skills without sparring.