Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Then why bother with a tournament that you know going in that you're not going to be judged "fairly" based on MA skills???
That's kinda like bringing a knife to a gun fight...
So why use forms/kata from other styles or systems. Just enter creative division, musical division, X-treme division, etc....if you just want to rack in trophies. There's enough divisions that you don't have to use forms/kata from other styles.
I can top the forms thing. I had a brown belt judging my division, 4th dan & up, at one of these tourneys. These guys are frigging wacked out.
That's why I never thought it was fair for a hard stylist to judge traditional style divisions that had traditional kung fu stylists in it but it happens all the time. Not only do they not know the soft styles but they are going to be biased and judge the traditional karate styles higher than the trad. kf styles. I had a TKD person judging my div one time. whats he know about kung fu???
After the competition, I told this young man that it would be easy for him to essentially dial-down his poomsae and do Koryo according to the KKW standard. I told him if he got permission from his instructor, I'd be happy to teach him.
TKD forms at a Karate tournament............ :eye-popping: :lfao: :wah: :moon:
And people wonder why those who train traditional don`t like to compete.
Open tournaments are perhaps the biggest waste of time and resources in the martial arts. This coming from someone who liked them in his youth. Then I realized most of what I was seeing (and *cough* doing) had no merit whatsoever in an actual physical encounter, so I quit that scene cold turkey.
I am amused by the original post. What does the karate guy say his style is when his is introducing himself to the judges? "Shoto kwan do?"
It depends on if you are the one throwing the tourney or not. A large number of the tourney promoters make a pretty healthy $$$ off of tourneys.
Most guys/girls that compete in open tourneys don't introduce the style they train in, most are a part of an independent team that represent a company orother team sponsor.
>>
I'm totally baffled. Why on earth would a Karate school teach TKD forms? Especially when you consider the fact that the older hyungs are either direct adaptations of, or recombinations of subsequences within, Okinawan/Japanese kata... what's the thinking here??? <<
Not so much pattern collection as trophy collection. The more divisions they enter, the more trophies they can collect.
Open tournaments are perhaps the biggest waste of time and resources in the martial arts. This coming from someone who liked them in his youth. Then I realized most of what I was seeing (and *cough* doing) had no merit whatsoever in an actual physical encounter, so I quit that scene cold turkey.
I am amused by the original post. What does the karate guy say his style is when his is introducing himself to the judges? "Shoto kwan do?"
I would disagree that open tournaments are a waste of time. Yes, they will never be what an actual physical encounter is like, but they can help you mentally deal with stress under pressured situations. Also, under the right coaching, they help you deal with what happens when you don't always win.
Oh..to answer your last question, for most tournament they don't have to mention their style anymore...they simply mention name, school & kata name.
I agree... It's not "martial" or "tough" to run out, SCREAM your kata and name (if that), and almost immediately launch into it. Years back, when I did a bit of open tournament stuff, you walked up, stood at attention, bowed, announced yourself, your school/style, instructors, and your form, and asked permission to begin... And in sparring, you took your lumps and kept going.Most don't even do that. They simply say who they are and who they represent. Then they do their form. IMO it borders on rude the way most do it. "Sport Karate" has turned into its own beast, not like how it was in the early years. No blood and guts anymore. Not to mention no groin kicking.
(Damn... some graying fogey snuck in here to my keyboard!)
I agree that while it has evolved in some areas it has de-evolved in others. Last night I was talking with my Sensei and he was speaking of the tournaments back in the 70's and how they would be inspect all the competitors and do exercises prior to the match.Most don't even do that. They simply say who they are and who they represent. Then they do their form. IMO it borders on rude the way most do it. "Sport Karate" has turned into its own beast, not like how it was in the early years. No blood and guts anymore. Not to mention no groin kicking.