people do figure things out, quite a lot all the time, give them a soccer ball and they figure it out, give them a tennis set and they figure it out, hell people learn fighting by fighting with their friends, thats rather how i learned to fight, they may figure it out sooner be better with expert coaching, but thats only so if the coaching is actually addressing the fundamental issues[/quote]
So you are (or would be) a lazy coach.
Every sport I've ever done has taught stance and movement.
- Soccer - how to move with the ball
- Football - there are different stances for linemen, and some are better at different stances than others are (you see this in scouting reports all the time)
- Basketball - how to move with the ball, your stance and footwork after you've grabbed hold of the ball, your stance while defending
- Baseball - batter's stance, infield stance. The pitcher's throw very much resembles a TMA front stance
What do you mean by "silly walk"? Because that type of walk is how Marshawn Lynch was such a powerhouse at bulldozing through defenders. That type of walk is what you see in ice hockey. That type of stance you see in basketball players who are defending or who are at risk of traveling.
Getting from point A to point B isn't the point of martial arts.
Strength training. Flexibility. Discipline. The fact that a lot of people regress under stress, and so exaggerating the motions can help counter that regression.
So you see it has some benefit, and then immediately reject. You're arguing with yourself in this paragraph.
No. It's because your points make no sense. I provided reasons and examples why everything you said was wrong (except for half of the previous paragraph). You are right that I can't use reason to convince you of your errors, because you're still arguing after you've so clearly been wrong.[/QUOTE]
im saying that different sports have more in common than they do differences, sports or positions that require fast moving dont plant themselves,NEVER . or if they make a mistake the game passes them by
.ice hockey player dont walk at all, it isn't a walk, that just how you have to move to SKATE , field hockey players dont move like that and apart from the skating aspect they are much the same, thats a silly point
teaching them to walk badly only means that when they are stressed they walk badly, ( or maybe less badly)people learnt to walk very early in life and do so when they are stressed as well , generally. another daft point
and of course fast A to B movement is the very essence of fighting( even if the two points are quite close together, your still at a different point in space)if its not an important point in any MA, then its not teaching you to fight very well or possibly at all ? Standing like a statue isnt really optimal, walking at the speed of a drunk even less so
the main difficulty in soccer isnt moving with the ball,( thats the easy part) its getting it in the first place and that commonly requires speed of movement with out the ball