Yoshiyahu
Master Black Belt
Oh well to be honest its not crosstraining Si-je shoots down. Crosstraining can be beneficial...
The part we disagree on is a new martial artist someone who has never studied any martial arts begins to learn martial arts for the first time an starts learning Tiger and Crane, Tae Kwon Do and Aikido. I don't think this would be as productive as someone learning Japanese Jiujitsu for three years before adding a new art such as Muay Thai. An then later add a third art. I think this way you have a great foundation. Now if you have studied WC for like five years already and you want to learn Hapkido and TKD I think that would be more beneficial if you have the time and money.
I see both pro's and con's to cross training.
Pro's
More than one art to draw from
Use different techniques to defeat an oppponent
Extra training can increase stamina
Con's
Start to get the arts confused or mesh together.
More money to learn two or more at the same time
Time taking away from perfecting one art.
Just to name a few. But learning another art could you more techniques to draw from an add to your fighting ability. As for Si-Je I believe her main point was BJJ is a comabative sport. An training BJJ will not prepare you for an actual fight. It will actually give you a false sense of confidence which could get you killed in the street. As for me I dont feel either way since Most BJJ people dont just study BJJ but also Muay Thai,Judo and boxing. So to me if their BJJ lacks something they will make up for it with Judo or MT. But this is my opinion.
But the whole idea of which style is better is nonsense...there are no unbeatable styles. Maybe an unbeatable fighter. But not style...WC is not even a style of Kung Fu...its a system.
As for BJJ...I never liked ground fighting much...I really dont care for it. I respect every martial art including Tae Kwon Do which many fighters today have no respect for. But Just because I respect an art doesn't mean I would like to learn it. So for me BJJ is merely something I dont like as perference. It has nothing to do with how valid or effective the art is.
The part we disagree on is a new martial artist someone who has never studied any martial arts begins to learn martial arts for the first time an starts learning Tiger and Crane, Tae Kwon Do and Aikido. I don't think this would be as productive as someone learning Japanese Jiujitsu for three years before adding a new art such as Muay Thai. An then later add a third art. I think this way you have a great foundation. Now if you have studied WC for like five years already and you want to learn Hapkido and TKD I think that would be more beneficial if you have the time and money.
I see both pro's and con's to cross training.
Pro's
More than one art to draw from
Use different techniques to defeat an oppponent
Extra training can increase stamina
Con's
Start to get the arts confused or mesh together.
More money to learn two or more at the same time
Time taking away from perfecting one art.
Just to name a few. But learning another art could you more techniques to draw from an add to your fighting ability. As for Si-Je I believe her main point was BJJ is a comabative sport. An training BJJ will not prepare you for an actual fight. It will actually give you a false sense of confidence which could get you killed in the street. As for me I dont feel either way since Most BJJ people dont just study BJJ but also Muay Thai,Judo and boxing. So to me if their BJJ lacks something they will make up for it with Judo or MT. But this is my opinion.
But the whole idea of which style is better is nonsense...there are no unbeatable styles. Maybe an unbeatable fighter. But not style...WC is not even a style of Kung Fu...its a system.
As for BJJ...I never liked ground fighting much...I really dont care for it. I respect every martial art including Tae Kwon Do which many fighters today have no respect for. But Just because I respect an art doesn't mean I would like to learn it. So for me BJJ is merely something I dont like as perference. It has nothing to do with how valid or effective the art is.
Oh I agree, and have from the start....just funny seeing you post it given your (and Si-Je) tendency to shoot down cross training in one thread and prop it up in another, hence the irony.