Guys, lets chill a bit and return to the main discussion. There was obviously a misunderstanding here regarding the clips. We have some good discussion going here, lets not let a misunderstanding ruin it.
George, just to clarify a point:
The clips in question are not of Jay, but of Paul Genge, a Systema instructor as well as a member of this forum. I believe Jay was simply talking about his own training that he has done in Systema on his own time. As I had said in another post regarding your question to me about my thoughts on them, I think that its pretty hard to get a true feel for something from a tape. Of course we're all entitled to our own thoughts on the art of Systema but IMHO we really can't get a true idea unless we 'feel' the techs. ourselves. It certainly is a very big difference from the art of Kenpo.
The clips, just like a SD tech. are showing/giving an idea or a possible response. Techniques IMO should not be set in stone, but instead used as a foundation to help the student build off of. Ultimately, we do want want to have to think about a tech. but instead react accordingly to what is thrown at us.
Anyway....back to the discussion.
Mike
George, just to clarify a point:
The clips in question are not of Jay, but of Paul Genge, a Systema instructor as well as a member of this forum. I believe Jay was simply talking about his own training that he has done in Systema on his own time. As I had said in another post regarding your question to me about my thoughts on them, I think that its pretty hard to get a true feel for something from a tape. Of course we're all entitled to our own thoughts on the art of Systema but IMHO we really can't get a true idea unless we 'feel' the techs. ourselves. It certainly is a very big difference from the art of Kenpo.
The clips, just like a SD tech. are showing/giving an idea or a possible response. Techniques IMO should not be set in stone, but instead used as a foundation to help the student build off of. Ultimately, we do want want to have to think about a tech. but instead react accordingly to what is thrown at us.
Anyway....back to the discussion.
Mike