My former Shotokan Karate Sensei trained under and received his Black Belt from Hidy Ochiai back in the 70s. He spoke very highly of him which then sparked my interest to find out more about Ochiai. My former Sensei told me about Ochiai's kata performances and demonstrations with the katana. He even said he was incredible in kumite. However, despite the incredible impression he gave me he did say that Ochiai had a huge ego. And as everyone else is concerned about Ochiai's background, so am I.
I have gone through many magazine articles featuring Ochiai and have looked through his books. All I can really say is what everyone already knows, that his background might trace back to a random temple, yet he cannot give information on this temple. The temple story definitely throws up a red flag. Even many of the anecdotes he has provided sound fraudulent. His background is most definitely questionable considering many Sensei's are very open about their backgrounds. Why Ochiai cannot be open about his background certainly baffles me.
There seems to be a majority agreement that Ochiai is talented, but in my opinion his kata tournament wins aren't really that impressive. There are many different tournaments/championchips with winners. Furthermore, some of his self-defense techniques are just plain silly. The multiple attacker techniques aren't really that practical.
I myself have had the opportunity to have participated in a local Connecticut tournament a few years back with Washin-Ryu participants. They were Black and Brown Belts, and I can say that I was not impressed. In fact, my former Sensei even said that they were terrible and commented on how Ochiai's standards must have taken a dive. If you are going to choose a Karate organization I would simply pick JKA, SKIF, SKA, or some other JKA-split organization. I myself am a fan of JKA's organized methods of training and the instructors have proven themselves. The history is also unquestionable.
I have gone through many magazine articles featuring Ochiai and have looked through his books. All I can really say is what everyone already knows, that his background might trace back to a random temple, yet he cannot give information on this temple. The temple story definitely throws up a red flag. Even many of the anecdotes he has provided sound fraudulent. His background is most definitely questionable considering many Sensei's are very open about their backgrounds. Why Ochiai cannot be open about his background certainly baffles me.
There seems to be a majority agreement that Ochiai is talented, but in my opinion his kata tournament wins aren't really that impressive. There are many different tournaments/championchips with winners. Furthermore, some of his self-defense techniques are just plain silly. The multiple attacker techniques aren't really that practical.
I myself have had the opportunity to have participated in a local Connecticut tournament a few years back with Washin-Ryu participants. They were Black and Brown Belts, and I can say that I was not impressed. In fact, my former Sensei even said that they were terrible and commented on how Ochiai's standards must have taken a dive. If you are going to choose a Karate organization I would simply pick JKA, SKIF, SKA, or some other JKA-split organization. I myself am a fan of JKA's organized methods of training and the instructors have proven themselves. The history is also unquestionable.