With a show like True Blood, with each episode only an hour long, there are three basic ways to depict American Soldiers fighting against men who murder innocent people as policy. You can show them as all good, all bad or in a more nuanced way depicting the stress of men in war and the effects it has on them. HBO chose to depict them in the worst way possible. Had this been one show, in an assortment of depictions coming from hollywood, then no big deal. The vast majority of movies and television shows depicting the fight against islamic radical terrorists have shown American soldiers, and marines in the worst way possible, as drug addicts, nut jobs, crazed killers or complete victims. This show is no different than the other depictions out there.
It is not American training doctrine to kill innocent civilians. Atrocities happen, as has been pointed out, due to putting normal people in war situations, but American training and policy does not include targeting innocent civilians. This is however, the policy of the actual people we are fighting. The lopsided view of who does what to who starts to permeate the culture, much like the previous examples of the "crazed" vietnam vet, which was a false depiction of the actual vets.
Since this is a show about vampires and werewolves, there was no expectation to go into a nuanced portrayal of war and its horrors, so they chose to show the worst qualities of our soldiers.
Yes, these things happen-the "worst qualities of our soldiers," though? I'm not so sure. After all, I think the character who was present for those events is a sympathetic one, if not one of the main characters, and at least appears to be conflicted if not remorseful about it.
Frankly, I find your analyses of these and other forms of literature and entertainment to be extremely myopic and one-sided, unnuanced and unintelligent: this is an event that is probably used by the writer to introduce nuance and depth-the "backstory," if you will-to one of the supporting characters, as well as give them their own story line for the season.
That is all. It's not about "the military." It's not about "the war in Iraq." It's not about "the U.S.A." It's about one character in a fictional account in a completely fabricated universe that is only related to ours in the most marginal of ways: the person whose head almost completely contains lives in ours with us, most of the time. Parts of the rest of the time, he lives in the universe of
True Blood, where the advent of synthetic blood has made vampires come out of the darkness after millenia in hiding, where werewolves walk, a waitress can read minds, voodoo works, and, yes, there is a "war on terror."
I mean, honestly-if atrocities
do occur,and troops
do take drugs and drink, they are going to be written about, one way or another.
Quite honestly, this one note criticism of yours has grown quite tiresome, and now, with this
True Blood thing, you've demonstrated amply just how ridiculous it is. :lfao:
And to how the Japanese portrayed us...
All of which does nothing to negate anything I said about the inherent racism of American society at the time, and our clearly racist attitudes towards the Japanese.
The beheading of prisoners was a common practice with the Japanese army, not something brought on by the stress of combat, but an actual approved practice. I read a story told by a Japanese officer in China where as a bonding and training excercise, each officer in the unit had to behead chinese prisoners. He remembered one officer who missed the cut, cutting the prisoner across the shoulder blade, and they had to chase the prisoner around as he ran about the compound, slashing at him to kill him. The Japanese also told the civilian population that the G.I.'s were cannibals and would eat anyone they captured.
Yes, and my ancestors beat people to death, set them on fire, and buried them up to the chin at shore below the tide line, and waited for the tide to come in for entertainment-actually, if the story is to be believed, my great-great-grandfather did that to a man when he got home from a long sea voyage. :lfao: