Different classes for age groups
- Thread starter 2000zac
- Start date
lklawson
Grandmaster
Yes to both. Depends on the instructor and, often, the size of the class.
If you're not comfortable with it, ask the instructor.
More importantly, to my mind, are adults sparring toddlers? If so, take video and post it. I suspect it would be entertaining.
Peace favor your sword,
Kirk
If you're not comfortable with it, ask the instructor.
More importantly, to my mind, are adults sparring toddlers? If so, take video and post it. I suspect it would be entertaining.
Peace favor your sword,
Kirk
frank raud
Master of Arts
Depends. When there is sufficient students, classes are usually split. But I have been in classes in a community center with approx. 50 students, 5 to 50. Of course, the instructor only has an hour or so allotted to him. In a private club, it would probably raise some eyebrows.
JR 137
Grandmaster
As has been said, circumstances pretty much dictate the schedule. Most established dojos keep kids and adults separate, with perhaps an all ages class at one time slot per week. If the dojo is new, they may have everyone train together until there's enough students to separate by age and rank.
Some dojos have different definitions of adult as well. Some consider adults 14+, some are 16 or 18+. Some allow students who aren't quite the age yet into adult classes if they're mature enough and skilled enough to be there. I'm not sure of the exact age cutoff between adults and children classes at my dojo (about 14), but there have been a few younger ones invited to train with the adults in certain classes, and others who've met the adult age have been told to stay in the children's classes. We're a small dojo, so case by case assessment works for us.
With all that said, I've never seen the littlest ones (say 4-6 years old) in with adults. I've seen adults assisting teaching the class, but not actually training together.
Some dojos have different definitions of adult as well. Some consider adults 14+, some are 16 or 18+. Some allow students who aren't quite the age yet into adult classes if they're mature enough and skilled enough to be there. I'm not sure of the exact age cutoff between adults and children classes at my dojo (about 14), but there have been a few younger ones invited to train with the adults in certain classes, and others who've met the adult age have been told to stay in the children's classes. We're a small dojo, so case by case assessment works for us.
With all that said, I've never seen the littlest ones (say 4-6 years old) in with adults. I've seen adults assisting teaching the class, but not actually training together.
As others have said.... it depends. I think for some kinds of classes, you can have kids and adults train together (especially if the adults are mostly the parents of the kids, so it's like a family bonding activity) and it works okay, but for other kinds of classes it doesn't. And where you can/should/need to draw the line can vary as well.
For example, in my experience, for a sport-oriented Taekwondo class, you can often have well-behaved 8-year olds train some things together with adults (though for sparring you'd put the kids together and the adults together), but you can't have 4-year olds train with either of those ages. For a strongly self-defense oriented class, on the other hand, putting adults and kids together at all would IMO be a bad idea.
For example, in my experience, for a sport-oriented Taekwondo class, you can often have well-behaved 8-year olds train some things together with adults (though for sparring you'd put the kids together and the adults together), but you can't have 4-year olds train with either of those ages. For a strongly self-defense oriented class, on the other hand, putting adults and kids together at all would IMO be a bad idea.
Midnight-shadow
3rd Black Belt
- Joined
- May 29, 2016
- Messages
- 928
- Reaction score
- 243
At the school I attend we split the adults and children (children being 15 years and younger), although there is one session a week that is a joint lesson for adults and children. The children also have a different grading structure to the adults which is another reason why the separation is a good thing. Personally I would hate to take lessons with the children as I put a lot of effort into my training and seeing the kids messing around and not take it seriously would just piss me off.
JR 137
Grandmaster
Even if the kids are as focused as adults, it's still an issue. Kids learn far slower and need more instruction on the most basic things (constantly reminded of stance, chambering their hand, proper fist, etc.). I've had to take the kids' class once or twice; it was that or nothing for the week due to my schedule. The kids were about 10-14. Not a complete waste of time, but not very productive either. I knew what I was getting into, so it didn't bother me. But if that was every training session, I wouldn't be around for very long.
KenpoMaster805
2nd Black Belt
It depense to your instructor like advance kids go with advance then beginners go with beginners kids then adult beginners intermediate and advance go together
KenpoMaster805
2nd Black Belt
I mostly teach beginners on friday and tuesday then thursday advance class like 3rd jr brown or mostly jr green students
In some schools, often smaller clubs have bigger groups due to scheduling difficulties. If you only have a few hours twice a week to work with there is only so much you can do.
I don't like it, different ages need different things in a class. For us we do 3-4 yrs, 5-7 yrs, 8-10 yrs, 11-14 yrs and then 15-adult.
Actually one of the things that drew me to my current Dojo is that they have adults only classes every evening. Not that I don't like kids but...Let's just say I prefer training with other adults. I had looked at other martial arts schools in my area and other than MMA schools (which I actually have taken and wasn't looking to go back to) most of the other schools seemed to have mixed age classes. Some split classes by ranks (i.e white through orange at x time) and some did separate out ages a little bit, but still combined teens and adults and it seemed that most schools definition of teen was 13. My current Dojo adult classes are for anyone over 18. Adults can take and earlier in the evening teen/adult class if they want, but it seems most adults take the adult class unless they have a child in the teen class. Plus after the adult class most of us hang out help straighten the Dojo up and then have a beer together.
Danny T
Senior Master
Different schools different class structure.
We have different age groups;
ages 4-5
ages 6-12 Level I
ages 6-12 Level II
ages 8-12 Advanced
ages 13-16
ages 17-up
We have different age groups;
ages 4-5
ages 6-12 Level I
ages 6-12 Level II
ages 8-12 Advanced
ages 13-16
ages 17-up
It is important, it's frightfully demoralising to be beaten by toddlers and they are just so agile and supple, damn them.
Danny T
Senior Master
There was a time I could destroy them. Now...it's embarrassing and ugly...they are quick, agile, and just keep coming non stop. Against them I was bad ***; today I'm just an old *** that's just bad.
Kickboxer101
Master Black Belt
- Joined
- Mar 30, 2016
- Messages
- 1,189
- Reaction score
- 312
It happens. In my gym everyone's around 17 and above I'd say at a guess 15 at the youngest. I don't think there's anything saying they can't have younger but I guess most parents don't want to put their little kids in kickboxing. Saying that there is a kids class on Saturday mornings that's only small. But the last few weeks we had a new kid he's about 13 and about 4'5 I think his dads friends with the coach which is why he's let him train with us. Now since we don't do huge amounts of sparring its not a safety issue but is fairly annoying when I got paired up with him last week and could barely even touch the pads as the first punch I threw was a light jab on a focus mitt and even that nearly sent him flying. Then we ended up doing jumping front kicks on the kicking shields so that was basically pointless for me since there was no way I could put even 5% in so that did piss me off because I couldn't put any power in on pads and I couldn't even work on speed or technique as he kept messing up where he was holding the pads so I do think having kids and adults train together isn't the best idea.
lklawson
Grandmaster
OTOH, it's pretty common for smaller teens to have to fight people who are bigger and stronger. Might suck for your training but it could be imperative for HIS. Instead of looking at it as a failure and a waste of time for your fight training, look at it as an opportunity for you as a coach, trainer, or temporary mentor.
Peace favor your sword,
Kirk
Danny T
Senior Master
Excellent points.
Learn by helping another grow. How do you think those who are above your skill sets and abilities feel about having to train with you?
Kickboxer101
Master Black Belt
- Joined
- Mar 30, 2016
- Messages
- 1,189
- Reaction score
- 312
Sure great but when I'm paying 10 pound for a class I expect to at least be able to train with some intensity
That is seriously expensive! for that I'd expect a private lesson.
lklawson
Grandmaster
Talk with your instructor. Tell him that you don't want to train with the kid any more. Report back.
Peace favor your sword,
Kirk
