Sgtmac,
I agree PPCT is not a great source or viable source of self defense for an all out brawl, and it's not meant to be!!
What people are failing to see in the larger picture, mainly the blinders of it not complete, when in reality PPCT and DT's for the most part is just as complete as any instructor makes it.
See PPCT is a guideline, a course program that as an LEO or DT's instructor one must follow for procedures of properly handeling a situation to make it sound better on documentation. Does this mean the PPCT or DT's as taught to be followed to the "T"? Not necessarily. If an LEO or CO, or whomever is needed to be trained in DT's has to defend themselves be it non-lethal force, to lethal force the force continum comes to play.
If im tackled do I start blasting the common peroneal nerve knowing it may or may not work? Or do I post guard or gain mount etc.. and choke the man out at all cost of saving my life? Does the situation require you to choke the assailant into complete unconciousness? Can you roll over your opponent and gain an straight arm bar, w/ a wrist type lock and control the suspect to calm him into submission? what about the use of pressure points to control and seize your opponent!! is it 100% effective? NO!! Nothing is...But an officer trained in PPCT or DT's that has 0(zero) training ever, has a much better fighting chance than that guy who has nothing not even PPCT DT's training.. A seasoned or skilled MA that has DT/PPCT training also well yes his / her chance of survival is greater!! But nonetheless the report has to read the same as an officer w/ less experience and thats what PPCT was devised for. When a judge reads over the report and the proper terminology is from the PPCT infrastructure is written, vs. that of an experienced MA and your using terms like Jump Spinning hook kick, and Spinning Backfist, or " I applied a guninting strike to the inside of the forearm followed up by a series of jik chung choy (chain punches) to the face of the guy" I mean does this make sense? Does this mean these cannot be used? NOT AT ALL, just don't report it if you did happend to use thes techiques. LOL just use the PPCT terms and you'll fair much better when the judge and the DA are reading over your report if Empty hand control had to be used!!! If you have to use an intermediate weapon the same applies as well...
Hope this helps those w/ o DT's training and are looking to teach LEO's Defensive Tactics. You must adhere to standard operating procedures.. YOu can't just go teach an officer to break ankles and knees if and when an altercation arises. You can and are and will be just in as much hot water as the teacher as the officer who uses it!!