I really like your post, I like how you point out factors of age that the average person does not see or recognizes. I am 57, and I am finding it harder to teach the younger generation compared to when I was young lol. They recognize my stature, but they keep contradicting me because of what they read or saw on Youtube, they see things more in the technical manner then the broad perspective. I am glad to see a student researching and not just take my word for it, but at least try the move or exercise out before contradicting. I tried suggesting to a man on another forum about using weights on his wrists and legs to build up strength in all directions, and not restrict his strength in a few directions. This turned out to be a very long discussion with another person, giving link's to various articles which to him stated opposite of what I was saying, which it was not lol. Do you have problems with the younger generation?
Thanks. I like your idea about the weights.
I haven't interacted with younger martial artists, given that only old Chinese people (and TCM students) seem to share interest in what I do (e.g. yiquan, qigong). We're soooo mild. I do remember one aggressive young guy a few years back in a push-hands class, but he got booted from the class eventually. I think he was angry with his father or something.
But I do have experience teaching graphics in college, and I see a tendency towards a reliance on remote information over direct experience. They want to buy the thing, take the course, watch the video, instead of getting dirty and actually
trying the thing. Not everyone, but I see a trend. Also as an amateur musician, I see a lot of online questions basically asking for the step-by-step process of learning jazz improvisation. Dudes. Internalize the scales, internalize the theory, listen to good players, but you also have to just dive in and give yourself permission to screw up. Experience the act directly. So yes, why don't they
try the move?
Also, westerners have been taught to drill down, to take things apart, rather than unify and see the bigger picture. Both are necessary micro and macro, forest and trees.
But yeah, we accept the authority of a YouTube video when the bar for authority is now a mouth, a camera, and a YouTube account. (sigh) Direct experience is necessary more than ever.
You might find this interesting: the author says that we have been using our left brains more than our right, and it has gotten us into trouble by focusing on the details, not the bigger picture. On theory and abstract constructs rather than direct experience.