What's your most controversial, non-political opinion?

Squeezing the toothpaste from the middle should be a felony.
 
Before my teacher's teacher GM Zhang Feng-Yan passed away, the last words that he told to my teacher was, "MA is 1 狠 (Hen) - vicious, 2 毒 (Du) - poison, 3 要命 (Yao Ming) - kill. Remember to pass this down to the next generation."
 
elder999 said:
Unless by "empty," you mean a lead-acid battery with no acid in it, this is simply incorrect.

The mass of an electron is 9.10938356 × 10 −31 kg.

"Full" batteries weigh just as much as "empty" ones, if by "full" and "empty" you are referring to charge.
Click to expand...
I could be wrong but I think the charged state is physically heaver by an infinitesimal amount due to the specific gravity.
 
In both fighter's prime, Muhammad Ali would whip Mike Tyson's butt. Or, the opposite.

See what I did there? Can't get mad at me, unless you find it confusing I guess. What are the rules again?
 
gpseymour said:
I’ll share what I put on your Facebook post: I’m not impressed by t music of either The Beatles or The Rolling Stones.
Click to expand...
Yes! I just never got into The Beatles... I know they were a very big deal for that time, (even though I wasn't around at that time), but I just can't get into them.
 
dvcochran said:
I could be wrong but I think the charged state is physically heaver by an infinitesimal amount due to the specific gravity.
Click to expand...
No. The charged state has a higher specific gravity because the electrolyte is denser.
The electrolyte is denser because it has more "stuff" in it.
The discharged state has a lower specific gravity because "stuff" has deposited on the anodes
.
jobo said:
no your error is in failing to recognise that adding energy adds mass, it has nothing to do with the weight of the electrons, . the same is true of compressing a spring, which then also weighs more

i
Click to expand...

Sigh.

For those following this, I'm going to take it as a teachable moment.

Let us consider, first, the cake. Or banana bread. I made two loaves today. I mixed up a batter, put it into the oven, and added energy to it in the form of heat. Did its mass increase? Did its weight increaseNo. In fact, odds are good that it decreased, even though it came out quite hot from added energy.

Let us then consider a rock in the sun. At afternoon, the rock is quite hot from having absorbed energy. In fact, here in New Mexico in the summer, you could well fry an egg on the rock, which has had energy added to it. Has its mass increased? Has its weight increased? No. Its volume has likely increased somewhat measurably, due to thermal expansion, but the "amount of stuff" (the engineer's definition of mass) has not increased. The potential energy due to distance from the center of the earth (part of the knuckle-dragging engineer's definition of weight) has not changed. It weighs the same.

Remember that potential energy, though.

If I take that same rock I was talking about, and put it up on a shelf, say three meters above the ground, I've increased its gravitational potential energy-it has more energy falling 9 meters to the ground than it does falling 5 or 6 cm.

More to the point, take that same rock to 10000 ft above the ground, or to the top of Everest, or to a plane at 35000 ft above ground, and each time its potential energy due to gravity has obviously increased, but its weight will actually (and measurably) decreased due to distance from the center of the earth.

The rock in Death Valley weighs more, but has less energy than the same rock on Mt. Everest.

Lastly, only way a spring weighs more compressed is by pushing against a scale, which isn't really measuring its "weight." Hold that spring compressed by binding it in some way, and put it on the scale, and the only difference will be the weight of the binding material.

The way a battery works, the flow of electrons is from cathode to anode-from the negatively charged pole that stores electrons to the positively charged one that attracts them-those little bits of "stuff." The flow of electrons is what we call "electricity," and its potential is what we call voltage. When a battery is discharged-zero voltage-it has lost all potential, and the electrons, the "stuff" are on the anode. Almost as though they were rocks that had fallen of a cliff (cathode) to the ground (anode). When we charge a battery, we are not "adding energy," we are pushing the electrons back to the cathode. We are not adding "stuff," in fact, the charged lead-acid battery may weigh less, due to lost hydrogen from the electrolyte-which is why we have to periodically add water. By charging the battery, you haven't really added anything-you have recatalyzed the chemical reaction that produces the flow of electrons called electricity.

To sum up: in most cases, there is no difference in weight between a charged battery and a discharged one.
 
Last edited:
JP3 said:
In both fighter's prime, Muhammad Ali would whip Mike Tyson's butt. Or, the opposite.

See what I did there? Can't get mad at me, unless you find it confusing I guess. What are the rules again?
Click to expand...
Mike Tyson had a hard time with tall guys with good jabs, right from the Golden Gloves and Olympic hopes to the end of his career.

Muhammad Ali was the very definition of a tall guy with a a great jab.
 
_Simon_ said:
Yes! I just never got into The Beatles... I know they were a very big deal for that time, (even though I wasn't around at that time), but I just can't get into them.
Click to expand...
The best band to ever come out of Liverpool was the Lightning Seeds.
elder999 said:
No. The charged state has a higher specific gravity because the electrolyte is denser.
The electrolyte is denser because it has more "stuff" in it.
The discharged state has a lower specific gravity because "stuff" has deposited on the anodes
.


Sigh.

For those following this, I'm going to take it as a teachable moment.

Let us consider, first, the cake. Or banana bread. I made two loaves today. I mixed up a batter, put it into the oven, and added energy to it in the form of heat. Did its mass increase? Did its weight increaseNo. In fact, odds are good that it decreased, even though it came out quite hot from added energy.

Let us then consider a rock in the sun. At afternoon, the rock is quite hot from having absorbed energy. In fact, here in New Mexico in the summer, you could well fry an egg on the rock, which has had energy added to it. Has its mass increased? Has its weight increased? No. Its volume has likely increased somewhat measurably, due to thermal expansion, but the "amount of stuff" (the engineer's definition of mass) has not increased. The potential energy due to distance from the center of the earth (the knuckle-dragging engineer's definition of weight) has not changed. It weighs the same.
Remember that potential energy, though.
If I take that same rock I was talking about, and put it up on a shelf, say three meters above the ground, I've increased its gravitational potential energy-it has more energy falling 9 meters to the ground than it does falling 5 or 6 cm.

More to the point, take that same rock to 10000 ft above the ground, or to the top of Everest, or to a plane at 35000 ft above ground, and each time its potential energy due to gravity has obviously increased, but its weight will actually (and measurably) decreased due to distance from the center of the earth.

The rock in Death Valley weighs more, but has less energy than the same rock on Mt. Everest.
The only way a spring weighs more compressed is by pushing against a scale, which isn't really measuring its "weight." Hold that spring compressed by binding it in some way, and put it on the scale, and the only difference will be the weight of the binding material.

The way a battery works, the flow of electrons is from cathode to anode-from the negatively charged pole that stores electrons to the positively charged one that attracts them-those little bits of "stuff." The flow of electrons is what we call "electricity," and its potential is what we call voltage. When a battery is discharged-zero voltage-it has lost all potential, and the electrons, the "stuff" are on the anode. Almost as though they were rocks that had fallen of a cliff (cathode) to the ground (anode). When we charge a battery, we are not "adding energy," we are pushing the electrons back to the cathode. We are not adding "stuff," in fact, the charged lead-acid battery may weigh less, due to lost hydrogen from the electrolyte-which is why we have to periodically add water.

To sum up: in most cases, there is no difference in weight between a charged battery and a discharged one.
Click to expand...
giphy.gif
 
Well... MLB did name it the 'Hall of Fame', not the 'Hall of Virtues' :):D:p.
And Damit, Pete IS a famous man, and arguably the best player the game has seen. Ban him from baseball AND put him in the Hall.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

During pandemic lockdown have you found any new hobbies or things that you really enjoy doing?

Previous Thread

Hope we're all staying healthy and in good shape during the pandemic

Next Thread

Similar threads

M
What are your opinions on Jake Mace?
2
Replies
30
Views
12K
Terrible Tim Witherspoon
Terrible Tim Witherspoon
goof321
suggestion advice or opinion?
Replies
15
Views
2K
Sukerkin
Sukerkin
Bob Hubbard
Stick Fighting Controversy, and a possible solution.
2
Replies
22
Views
3K
tellner
tellner
Makalakumu
Scientists prove that politics wrecks your ability to reason
Replies
2
Views
1K
Makalakumu
Makalakumu
Empty Hands
Justice and Revenge
2 3
Replies
43
Views
5K
Twin Fist
Twin Fist

Latest Discussions

Back
Top