Hollywood1340
2nd Black Belt
Oooh boy. Here we go again. And of course judoinfo crashed, you've over loaded it by looking up the "truth". Nice turn away above btw
OP
Patrick Skerry
Guest
- Thread Starter
- #22
And your further thoughts regarding the golden score are?Hollywood1340 said:
Flatlander
Grandmaster
Mod Hat off.
My thoughts regarding the 'Golden Score' are: should one choose not to practice one's art as a sport, one should care not about sporting rules. Furthermore, should one refuse to answer others' questions regarding their martial education in a consistent fashion, one is usually a troll. An illegitimate poster. One without credibility. An armchair martial artist. A wanna be.
Those are my thoughts on the 'Golden Score'.
My thoughts regarding the 'Golden Score' are: should one choose not to practice one's art as a sport, one should care not about sporting rules. Furthermore, should one refuse to answer others' questions regarding their martial education in a consistent fashion, one is usually a troll. An illegitimate poster. One without credibility. An armchair martial artist. A wanna be.
Those are my thoughts on the 'Golden Score'.
what's the difference between the golden score and a regulation judo match...where it can be one by a single ippon...regular judo matches are sudden death, too...
OP
Patrick Skerry
Guest
- Thread Starter
- #25
Excellent question, that is the whole point, why the 'Golden Score' in the first place? What was on the IJF's mind? The promotion of $port$ or the betterment of judo?bignick said:
so, patrick, how long have you been studying judo
OP
Patrick Skerry
Guest
- Thread Starter
- #27
flatlander said:
OP
Patrick Skerry
Guest
- Thread Starter
- #28
Since I was eight, I made Shodan two months ago. All through local and regional shiais, round robin, and the bad point system.bignick said:
Flatlander
Grandmaster
Absolutely. This would be a function of your instructor, not the art. If there is difficulty in finding non-sport oriented instruction, what does that tell you about the state of the art itself?Patrick Skerry said:
OP
Patrick Skerry
Guest
- Thread Starter
- #30
Not so much the state of the art, or of the instructor who also might have reservations, but the state of the governing body, or 'bodies' as in the case for judo.flatlander said:
holy crap...a straight answer...although there is plenty of evidence that supports that you are really jack stay...or at least the person behind the jack stay persona...honestly...i don't think there are too many people that think you're only 19Patrick Skerry said:
OP
Patrick Skerry
Guest
- Thread Starter
- #32
But I do believe that you are a Rokyu in judo.bignick said:
yes i am...and i'm honest about it...
just as honest as i was the time you asked me who my instructors were...and i told you...like i've asked you, but you've never even acknowledged the request...
i've been studying judo and jujutsu, both, for two years and have not tested from yellow belt to orange because i'm not that concerned about rank...i'm in it for the love of judo
just as honest as i was the time you asked me who my instructors were...and i told you...like i've asked you, but you've never even acknowledged the request...
i've been studying judo and jujutsu, both, for two years and have not tested from yellow belt to orange because i'm not that concerned about rank...i'm in it for the love of judo
OP
Patrick Skerry
Guest
- Thread Starter
- #34
But you weren't being honest when you wrote you weren't coming back to this thread. You are too inconsistant to be taken seriously. Hecklers are routinely ignored in my dojo!bignick said:
Flatlander
Grandmaster
Which dojo is that?Patrick Skerry said:
OP
Patrick Skerry
Guest
- Thread Starter
- #36
You know flatlander, to be perfectly honest, based on some of the odd responses to my posts, I really don't want to identify my dojo here.flatlander said:
P.S. I just came back from a monthly shiai, and the Golden Score was used twice. Neither brown belt competitor had ever heard of it before.
Flatlander
Grandmaster
Fair enough, you're not required to provide that information if you're not comfortable doing so.Patrick Skerry said:
you're having trouble keeping your ducks in a row...i never said i was leaving this thread...Patrick Skerry said:
OP
Patrick Skerry
Guest
- Thread Starter
- #39
Just to remain on topic, and with an intelligent question from this rokyu, not all regulation judo matches are sudden death overtime, which is the Golden Score.bignick said:
During your initial four minute match (it used to be 12 minutes & 15 minutes in the Olympics), you can acuire points or penalties as time progresses. But with the Golden Score, the first point or penalty decides the match.
But will this improve judo? As the participants don't really care how they win in sudden death overtime, they'll do anything to win, particularly in major championships. So this is one of the controversies of the 'Golden Score', it is just another way to promote attacking judo and not good judo.
an ippon wins the match, as does a tap out or a choke out...at any time...yes there are various other ways to score and accumulate points...but every judo match is "sudden death" in the fact that it can be ended at any point...
