Originally posted by Red Blade
The other problem I have is that Dr. B has said that this event will give people the opportunity to prove whether or not they are worthy of the rank or titles that Professor awarded them.
Food for thought--
Red Blade,
While waiting for you to respond to several posts, I have lunching on the 'food for thought' that you provided above. Then I re-read your quotation from DocB which was as follows, in part:
"There has been a lot of talk about titles and rank, but in the end doesn't all come down to ability? The titles and rank are paper oriented, but ability is both demonstrated and apparent when viewed by others. My goal for the 2003 Symposium is to give all of the instructors the opportunity to demonstate their Modern Arnis ability regardless of rank and title. There will be a good number of conversations, there will be time to discuss the similarities and differences in approaches, but the telling differences will be in ability and presentation"
As I read this quote, I failed to see where or how DocB has said that he or anyone else would be determining if people were worthy of the rank that Professor gave them. He has stated that rank certificates are merely paper items (my paraphrase). He has stated that the Symposium will give all of the instructors an opportunity "...to demonstrate their Modern Arnis abilty regardless of rank and title."
Why are you and some others seemingly so frightened by the prospect of trained martial artists being judged on their demonstrated abilities wihin the art? The man NEVER said:
"that this event will give people the opportunity to prove whether or not they are worthy of the rank or titles that Professor awarded them."
Those are YOUR words! DocB is saying something totally different. He does not care what rank or title someone has been awarded. He is looking to see what their actual ability level is without any regard for the rank held within the IMAF or issued by Professor. The very key word in DocB's statement is "regardless" and that puts the burden squarely on the people taking center stage to teach at the Symposium. This is exactly why a number of invited persons declined their invitations. They were going to have to operate outside of the friendly confines of their close circle of freinds and supporters.
Red, we are all in the business of testing ourselves within the arts. In the pure art form of the "do" tradition, studying the art was intended to test ones self against one's own fears/doubts.
As our abilities improve, we should be reducing the "angst" and ultimately emerge as a "free and confident person". We should be able to use our martial arts training in every aspect of our lives to improve ourselves as we deal with others.
At it's heart and soul Modern Arnis is a combat art and not a "do".
If people are going to be afraid to step forward and compare their skills to those of others, then the true purpose of the training has been lost. In following the symposium thread, no one ever issued a "challenge to fight or engage in combat." What was offered was a chance for any number of people to come together and share their ideas and impressions of Modern Arnis. The requires that one must be willing to have their skills and abilities compared with those of other instructors. A number of so called leaders of Modern Arnis totally declined to accept the invitation to participate. I have noticed that DocB, Does Not spend any time or posts commenting on those people! He is acting in a positive and forward mode. He is focusing totally on the people who will be at the Modern Arnis Symposium.
You have questioned his abilities with your comment about being an "armchair arnisador" yet his response was actually quite positive and non-confrontational. He offered to meet you for breakfast, conversation and to be your training partner for the morning session at the WMAA Camp. A very nice gesture. He did not have to do either.
Skill and ability are the name of the game. Titles are nice, certificates are for displaying on walls, but in the end, when we go to martial arts schools, seminars, camps, tournaments and symposiums, it is the ability of the instructors that we focus on. Why spend your money on someone who is marginally skilled when a better more knowledgable instructor is available. The upcoming Modern Arnis Symposium is a talent show. The people willing to step forward to teach are confident, self assured indiviuals who accepted a challenge and opportunity. They love their art - Modern Arnis - and they are going to be in Buffalo, NY on July 11, 12 & 13, 2003 to have fun, share, exchange and learn from one another. My hat is off to all of the instructors who are scheduled to be at the Modern Arnis Symposium.
I hope that you get there.
Lamont