- Thread Starter
- #21
Who is going to stop you?
No-one can ever stop anybody, this is a converstation board so I am asking and telling stories. Just wanted to get other people perspective on things.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Who is going to stop you?
No-one can ever stop anybody, this is a converstation board so I am asking and telling stories. Just wanted to get other people perspective on things.
Unless your teacher says something, I wouldn't worry about that sort of thing.
And weight is not an issue for me. In case anyone wonders what I look like...
Accept? Yes.The other side of the question,should you accept a student who is overweight.
I like to see all sizes and genders on a demo team,so prospective students can see that TKD is for everyone.
I have never seen an overweight Korean born instructor though.
Then again, maybe that's why he's never had a lot of students.
ladies' man!
My karate teacher, an Okinawan, wasn't shy about making pointed remarks about building strength and getting/staying in shape. We always spent at least half an hour shirtless during practice for Sanchin kata, so there was no avoiding it either.
Then again, maybe that's why he's never had a lot of students.
I personally do not think that the tenants of TKD have any bearing what so ever on weight or weight control.
I think that commercial success and success as a teacher are completely unrelated, and to try and link the two is a mistake.To me, that's one of the marks of a great teacher, the fact that he/she has very little students. Most of my best teachers are commercial failures, at least at the point when I become involved with them. Jedi only have one padawan at a time for a reason.
I put stock in body fat percentage. A caliper test is the minimum I'd use to get this, though. I wouldn't depend on the bioelectric meters that some scales have on them. Your chance of even getting the same reading twice is pretty low, much less getting an accurate reading.jks9199 said:BMI is BS. There are solid correlations between waist size and some adverse medical implications including diabetes and heart disease. Correlation is not causation...
BMI doesn't take into account build. I am overweight. Significantly, to be blunt. By the height/weight charts and BMI, morbidly. I carry more bone and muscle than the charts say I should weigh in at total... Funny, the docs at occupational health didn't laugh when I asked which leg I should cut off to meet the charts.
That all said -- your weight is not correlationally related to your skill or teaching ability. Anyone who says it is needs to rethink things...
Were there any women in that class?
At 5'9 & 257lbs, you're not 'considered obese in todayworld'; medically, you're considered not just obese, but morbidly obese. Your weight will (if it is not already) lead directly to significant health problems. Obviously, you'd do well to lose a bunch of weight. Equally obviously, if it were easy, you'd not be posting this message, and all the internet advise in the world won't drop a single pound. In fact, you might gain weight while you're sitting at the desk with your cookies & Dr Pepper reading. Certainly, steroids are known to cause weight gain, but it is possible to control that, at least to some extent. I don't know why you're taking them, but you really ought to talk to your PCP about your options. Whatever benefit you're getting from the steroids certainly won't do you much good if the weight gain leads to your being crippled by heart attack or stroke, or even just because the weight makes your bad knees that much worse, that much sooner.
But your weight is a seperate issue from your teaching. Teaching is the passing on of knowledge, and your weight problems don't lessen your knowledge. And the effectiveness of your teaching can best be judged by the results, as demonstrated by your students.
I will say this. One of my sword instructors was a man built much like you. While he didn't move fast for long, his techniques were amazing, his hand speed incredible, and his speed over short distances impressive. His weight certainly didn't keep him from teaching me an awful lot.
Were there any women in that class?
Pretty judgmental...not a fan of this post...Tal