Mr. Zhu Huaiyuan - Yang Style Tai Chi (Old Sixth Form)

[windwalker099]

Do you have any example that one uses "push" to set up a punch or a throw? I just cannot image how that will work.

My friend just made this video—it might answer your question.

 

[Same Trick]

Didn't you just read on another forum that words were used to articulate this topic?

Funny how some people say it is difficult to articulate in words, yet all the words used to articulate it were written over 1000 years ago. Here however, "we may need to leave it at that". We shall see.

?? So you’re not writing a book on this topic. You could just have said something as - No I’m not writing a lot !

Edit -
Ah - sorry, I see, you thought that smiley was meant for you, but no it wasn’t , sorry if that somehow made upset

 

[Kung Fu Wang]

My friend just made this video—it might answer your question.

That's "sticky" and not "push".

 

[windwalker099]

That's "sticky" and not "push".

I'll let him know.

 

[Appledog]

?? So you’re not writing a book on this topic. You could just have said something as - No I’m not writing a lot !

Edit -
Ah - sorry, I see, you thought that smiley was meant for you, but no it wasn’t , sorry if that somehow made upset

I have no idea what you are talking about, nor why you posted a smiley, nor why you think I am writing a book.

I don't even know what we're talking about on this thread.

 

[Same Trick]

I have no idea what you are talking about, nor why you posted a smiley, nor why you think I am writing a book.

I don't even know what we're talking about on this thread.

Ok I can not understand why your say this now, maybe because someone had your post on that forum deleted.
Anyway in there you mentioned your upcoming book and put out a snippet that speak of specifics very much as the OP of this thread speaks.
I just thought that if you’re working on a book on this topic it could be of interest here in this thread

I have no idea what you are talking about, nor why you posted a smiley, nor why you think I am writing a book.

I don't even know what we're talking about on this thread.

Ok you seem upset, but I can understand why your say what you say here now, probably because that someone had your post on that forum deleted.
Anyway in there you mentioned your upcoming book and put out a snippet that speak of specifics very much as the OP of this thread speaks.
I just thought that if you’re working on a book on this topic it could be of interest here in this thread too.
If you are upset, don’t be, and as I said, the smiley that came inserted in my post was not meant pointing toward you, I have some technical trouble with this webpage and I felt at that moment my technical limitations was interestingly amusing.nothing more than that.



Edit:
See there it came again, the technical issue I have here, I have to constantly reload this webpage and it cause some trouble in posting , also keep in mind I’m not a native English speaker so I keep editing my swenglish so it hopefully comes out as I intend it to be, please have patience with me on this

 

[windwalker099]

have no idea what you are talking about, nor why you posted a smiley, nor why you think I am writing a book.

The book was mentioned in another forum, citing "Understanding the State of 'Shang Shou'"

The article used for this thread, as one of the topics in the book.

Might be something worth looking into if it wasn’t your post.

 

[windwalker099]

Understanding the State of “Shang Shou”
By Tang Fengch:
practitioners may adopt the same posture and appear outwardly similar, but one may have achieved Shang Shou, while the other has not. This difference is subtle and profound."

Words of wisdom, allowing for the many viewpoints expressed here.
Thanks to everyone for an interesting discussion.