Tgace
Grandmaster
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2003
- Messages
- 7,766
- Reaction score
- 409
- Thread Starter
- #21
The question i have is I swore an oath the the state and federal constitution if a law is passed that I believe is a violation of either I have a duty not to enforce it. In this case these departments have decided the law unconstitutional. I do it on a local level. We had a banning list for our housing authority I personally refuse to enforce it because I don't believe the city should have the power to ban a person from visiting family or friends. Eventually the courts agreed with me when the ACLU got involved and the banning list we had with 1000s of names was declared illegal and was thrown out. Same thing in my opinion as this. Or another example is the housing authority staff will call and ask us to search peoples houses for drugs or weapons and they always show me a lease that says they have the right to search an apartment at any time. I always refuse because I don't believe a lease supersedes the Constitution.
Good point. When one takes an oath to protect and defend the Constitution what does that mean in the real world...beyond just sounding good? On one hand we can't cant violate the Constitution under the excuse of "just following orders", but I get the impression that people here are also saying that we don't have the authority to decide whats unconstitutional either...