Robert Sterling
White Belt
I have read in a blog that the brachial stun can easily shut a person down with one touch, Do you guy think this technique is effective in a street fight.
Is brachial stun effective for real fight
- Thread starter Robert Sterling
- Start date
-
- Tags
- brachial stun
It can be. Here is a video of a Karate exponent utilizing it on a pimp:
They describe it as a forearm to the chin but it looks like a strike to the neck.
They describe it as a forearm to the chin but it looks like a strike to the neck.
I'm pretty sure they are faking it in that video.
These seem a little more realistic:
Midnight-shadow
3rd Black Belt
- Joined
- May 29, 2016
- Messages
- 928
- Reaction score
- 243
There's a big difference between something working, and being able to pull it off in a "real" fight. A back spinning kick to someone's head is more than likely going to knock that person out, but can you manage such a move when the other person is fighting back?
JR 137
Grandmaster
Yet more proof that pimpin' ain't easy.
True. In person, I've only seen it work once.....used by a 2nd person coming from behind to help.
I could see it working as a preemptive strike before the fight actually starts.
The karate instructor definitely kept his pimp hand strong!
Martial D
Senior Master
- Joined
- May 18, 2017
- Messages
- 3,408
- Reaction score
- 1,156
Yes, it works pretty much every time. It's only useful as a first strike though, you'll never land this if the dude has his hands up.
- Joined
- Aug 3, 2015
- Messages
- 14,677
- Reaction score
- 6,335
It's a good ole fashion "Karate Chop" to the side of the neck. The thing that I like about this video is that the Martial artist didn't wait for the guy to swing on him. He executed his technique first which is how it should be done. Don't wait until the chaos of flying fist begin to try it, because it would only make it more difficult to execute the technique. To be honest the opportunity may not present itself again once fists start flying. Martial Arts gets romanticize too much with "honorable this" and "honorable that." He used his skill exactly the way he was supposed to. Get straight to business and finish it.
I agree he did exactly what he should have done. However, I don't think it violated any of the codes of karate that emphasize 'no first strike'. I think that is a very good code, but one that is misunderstood. It does NOT mean you have to stand there and wait for the first punch. It means you don't instigate a fight, you don't 'start' the fight.
The presumed pimp in this case had already come charging at the victim, ready to do violence. That much is quite clear. In most jurisdictions in the US, that's assault, right there. You don't have to wait (in the law or according to any karate codes) for the first punch to be thrown to defend yourself. You have ALREADY been assaulted. Get busy defending yourself; this is what the man did.
I get told all the time by people who do not understand the codes of karate that my style is useless because I have to wait for the first punch. Yeah, no. Somebody comes chest-bumpin' up in my space with their jaw flappin', I'm going to fists immediately, no delays. Doesn't violate any codes that I know of, nor does it violate the law.
Of course, one could say that thankfully due to my training, I might just be able to handle being swung at once; I've been told I'm a pretty good counterpuncher.
"No first strike" doesn't mean I have to wait to get hit. At least not to me. Of course, I get told all the time by various people what it is that I believe, which is amazing considering they don't know me and have zero idea what my training is. I know you and I are of pretty similar mind, so I'm not referring to you, of course.
drop bear
Sr. Grandmaster
- Joined
- Feb 23, 2014
- Messages
- 23,943
- Reaction score
- 8,690
The issue you have is that it is thrown with the wrong hand. You attack a side that they can cover. And leave open a side they can attack.
So you have to play with a lot of tricky angles to make it work.
I was not a fan of it. But have played with it and there are some places you can use it if your fight goes into a technical exchange.
So you have to play with a lot of tricky angles to make it work.
I was not a fan of it. But have played with it and there are some places you can use it if your fight goes into a technical exchange.
JR 137
Grandmaster
Why didn't I think of that?
Yes, but it isn't magic. You better be Jackie Chan, if it doesn't work.
Charlemagne
Black Belt
Beat me to it.
Charlemagne
Black Belt
Juany118
Senior Master
- Joined
- May 22, 2016
- Messages
- 3,107
- Reaction score
- 1,053
If you look at the ranks it's not joking, also the way he drops. If it is a set up, dang good acting. Long story short though it does work, but you need to use it at the right moment. If you force it, it's going to fail.
Last edited:
