Very good thread/topic and an important one.
Personally my (certified) first aid training has been somewhere along the lines of
Advanced First Aid by the Red Cross (which they no longer teach and to my understanding turned out to be roughly EMT level at the time) ... no longer certified in that anyway.
First Responder, which included the basic CPR, First Aid... that certification lapsed a while back.
Wilderness First Aid, which is to say is basic first aid with a few specialty treatments thrown in (snake/animal bites, poisoned by wild plants mistakenly eaten, etc.), was told the cert was for life but lost the paperwork/card some years ago so... :idunno:
I would very much like to get re-certified in First Responder at least. I can't stand the thought of seeing someone in need of help and not doing anything. I'd want the same if it were me.
I usually try to keep a moderate first aid kit in my vehicle and a smaller simpler one in my (caving) pack.
IMO all students should learn because of the nature of the training involved. Accidents happen during training and it's a good idea to be able to at least DO something more than just call 911.
On the "Good Samaritan Law" comments... I agree that it sucks pretty much and is a double edged sword in some states. My cave-rescue instructor who was a (licensed) paramedic at the time (now retired) told me that he wouldn't do CPR on anyone ... especially in a cave away from Defib equipment because he said that legally once you START CPR you cannot STOP doing it until the person is turned over to other EMS or is hooked up to a Defibrillator for reasons that CPR is very tiring and if you stop and the person dies you could be held to blame for not keeping their heart pumping.
Basically the damned if you do and damned if you don't laws were written by those same type of detestable lawyers who'd sue you for defending yourself against a psychotic serial killer.
So coming up on an accident or someone in serious need of first aid I'm gonna help and stay with them til EMS arrives and then quietly fade off in the background. Damned what the lawyers say. They'd probably think different if they're in their wrecked vehicle and bleeding to death and see a bunch of people standing around not making a move to help because they might get sued for doing so.
OK, I used to teach that advanced first aid class when I was an EMT.. it was not and is not a first responder level, and defiantly not an EMT level.. you were not taught to use airways of any kind, or to prep IV's or to use mass trousers, or do injections or deal with any number of things that an EMT has to know.
if you treat as a "first aider" you are not a medical professional with a state or federal license/certification.. this means that most states good Samaritan laws do protect you!
You are not bound by law to meet the "standards of care" and some other things, and are not a "medical professional" under the laws.
I don't care about getting sued.. but charged with felony or capital murder is a completely different animal! that is the damned difference!
you do not face that possible outcome.. I would according to the attorney that I consulted back then. so you feel free to do so. I was the same way, but now because of the stupid way some of the laws are written, I can not help.. I can call 911 and that is about all I can do for you. if you are not my family or a very few 4 or so other people, so sorry but you are on your own. I might advise a bystander that some one should do so and so.. but touch you.. nope.. that leaves me open to to much legal jeopardy! I have found over the years that the old cynical adage is true: "no good deed will go unpunished more often then not."
if you had the state/federal certification of First Responder , that used to be 45 hours or so of training and continuing ed to keep it, and its expired, go consult an attorney before you find out some how you are in the same boat and face serious criminal charges possibly if things go sour and you did treat to that level... not sure if you do as an ex First Responder... but at least I was told I do as an ex EMT.